M. Loebl
Abstract:A construction supporting a conjecture that different ground state pairs exist in the 2-dimensional Edwards-Anderson Ising spin glass is presented.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?
This paper aims to explore whether there are different ground state pairs (GSPs) in two - dimensional Ising spin glasses (2D Edwards - Anderson Ising spin glass). Specifically, the author proposes a combinatorial structure to support the following hypothesis: there are incongruent ground state pairs in two - dimensional Ising spin glasses.
#### Background and Problem Statement
1. **Research Background**:
- A fundamental problem in understanding disorder and frustration effects is to determine the multiplicity of infinite - volume ground states in finite - dimensional realistic models.
- There is a conjecture, similar to the mean - field Sherrington - Kirkpatrick model, that finite - dimensional short - range systems have an infinite number of pairs of ground states.
- Another conjecture based on droplet - scaling theory predicts that there is only one pair of ground states.
2. **Research Object**:
- The simplest system for studying these problems is the two - dimensional Edwards - Anderson Ising model.
- Newman and Stein's research supports the hypothesis that there is only one pair of ground states. However, the goal of this paper is to propose a combinatorial structure to support the competing hypothesis, that is, there are incongruent ground state pairs.
3. **Core Problems**:
- **Hypothesis 1**: When the coupling constants \( J_{ij} \) in the square lattice are randomly selected, there is a probability strictly greater than zero such that there are incongruent ground state pairs.
- **Hypothesis 3**: For randomly selected coupling constants \( J_{ij} \), there are nested sequences of finite sub - lattices \( S_i \), such that the c - ground state pairs in these sub - lattices are finitely incongruent in the limit.
4. **Research Methods**:
- The author considers finite sub - lattices with different boundary conditions and defines a weaker concept of incongruence: if a domain wall between two states contains a two - way infinite path, then the two states are finitely incongruent.
- By studying strip lattices, the author proves that Hypothesis 3 holds in this case.
5. **Conclusions and Significance**:
- This paper proposes Hypothesis 4 and Hypothesis 5, which only involve finite sub - lattices and can therefore be directly studied by discrete methods and computer simulations.
- If Hypothesis 4 or Hypothesis 5 holds, it can be deduced that there are incongruent ground state pairs, thus supporting the competing hypothesis regarding the ground - state diversity in two - dimensional Ising spin glasses.
### Summary
This paper attempts to challenge and verify the problem of the diversity of ground - state pairs in two - dimensional Ising spin glasses by proposing new combinatorial structures and hypotheses. The author pays special attention to the existence of incongruent ground state pairs and, by introducing finite sub - lattices and a weaker concept of incongruence, provides a new research perspective and supporting evidence for this problem.