R. Mélin
Abstract:The aim of this paper is to explain the non monotonic temperature dependence of the self-consistent superconducting gap of ferromagnet/superconductor/ferromagnet (F/S/F) trilayers with weak ferromagnets in the parallel alignment (equivalent to F/S bilayers). We show that this is due to Andreev bound states that compete with the formation of a minigap. Using a recursive algorithm we discuss in detail the roles of various parameters (thicknesses of the superconductor and ferromagnets, relative spin orientation of the ferromagnets, exchange field, temperature, disorder, interface transparencies).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explain the non - monotonic behavior of the self - consistent superconducting energy gap with temperature in a parallel - arranged ferromagnet/superconductor/ferromagnet (F/S/F) trilayer structure. Specifically, when a weak ferromagnet is used, the superconducting energy gap of this trilayer structure first increases as the temperature decreases, reaches a maximum value, and then decreases to zero.
### Main Problems and Solutions
1. **Problem Description**:
- In the F/S/F trilayer structure, especially when the ferromagnet is a weak ferromagnet and the magnetic moments are arranged in parallel, the superconducting energy gap is observed to exhibit non - monotonic characteristics with temperature.
- This phenomenon cannot be directly explained by traditional superconducting theories, because traditional theories predict that the superconducting energy gap should decrease monotonically with temperature.
2. **Solution**:
- The author explains this phenomenon by introducing Andreev bound states. The competition between these bound states and the superconducting minigap leads to the non - monotonic temperature dependence of the superconducting energy gap.
- A recursive algorithm is used to discuss in detail the influence of various parameters (such as the thickness of the superconducting and ferromagnetic layers, the relative spin orientation, the exchange field, the temperature, the degree of disorder, and the interface transparency) on this non - monotonic behavior.
### Key Formulas and Concepts
- **Non - Monotonic Behavior of the Superconducting Energy Gap**:
\[
\Delta(T) \text{ increases first with temperature } T, \text{ reaches a maximum value and then decreases to zero}
\]
- **Andreev Bound States**:
Andreev bound states are special quantum states formed by electron scattering at the interface between a superconductor and a ferromagnet, and their energies are located inside the superconducting energy gap.
- **Recursive Algorithm**:
The recursive algorithm is used to calculate the Green's function in a multilayer structure, so as to solve the self - consistent equations of Andreev bound states and the superconducting energy gap more efficiently.
### Conclusion
Through detailed theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the author shows that the competition between Andreev bound states and the superconducting minigap is the main reason for the non - monotonic temperature dependence of the self - consistent superconducting energy gap in the F/S/F trilayer structure. This finding not only explains the experimentally observed phenomenon, but also provides a new perspective for further research on the physical mechanism at the interface between superconductors and ferromagnets.
### Graphic and Textual Explanation
- **Figure 3**: It shows the change of the self - consistent superconducting energy gap with temperature in the F/S/F trilayer structure under different layer thickness conditions. It can be seen that within certain parameter ranges, the superconducting energy gap does show a trend of first increasing and then decreasing.
- **Figure 4**: It shows the local density of states (LDOS) of the superconducting layer in the F/S/F trilayer structure under different tunneling amplitudes. The existence of Andreev bound states and their behavior with the change of tunneling amplitude can be observed.
Through these analyses, the paper successfully explains the non - monotonic temperature dependence of the self - consistent superconducting energy gap in the F/S/F trilayer structure and reveals the underlying physical mechanism.