Eric S. Swanson
Abstract:A review and critique of the Isgur-Paton flux tube model of hadronic physics is presented. This entails a detailed comparison with recent lattice gauge theory results which exposes both the successes and shortcomings of the model. Applications to hybrid masses, meson and hybrid meson decays, hadronic charge radii, the spin-orbit force, baryonic hybrids, and hybrid photocouplings are also discussed. Finally, I comment on the issue of adiabatic surface crossing which appears in both the flux tube model and lattice studies.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate and improve the application of the Isgur - Paton Flux Tube Model (FTM) in strong - interaction physics, especially for the description of low - energy Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Specifically, the author Eric S. Swanson conducts a detailed review and criticism of the flux tube model and compares it with the latest lattice gauge theory results to reveal the successes and shortcomings of this model.
### Main problems include:
1. **Basis and Predictions of the Model**:
- The author reviews the basic assumptions and predictions of the flux tube model and compares them with lattice gauge theory or other theoretical tests.
- The model attempts to construct a tractable low - energy QCD model through string - like gluon degrees of freedom. In particular, in the heavy - quark limit, gluons will rearrange into flux tubes, allowing quarks to move on the adiabatic gluon energy surface.
2. **Application of the Model**:
- The model is applied to hybrid state masses, meson and hybrid meson decays, hadron charge radii, spin - orbit forces, baryon hybrid states, and hybrid - photon couplings, etc.
- The adiabatic surface - crossing problem is particularly discussed, which is a phenomenon that occurs in both the flux tube model and lattice studies.
3. **Extension of the Model**:
- The extensions and new applications of the original model are explored, including the introduction of new assumptions and corrections to better describe experimental data.
4. **Verification of the Model**:
- Through numerical calculations and the results of lattice gauge theory, the validity of the small - oscillation approximation and the adiabatic approximation is examined.
- The potential energy predicted by the flux tube model is compared with the results calculated by lattice gauge theory, and it is found that the model has some problems in short - distance behavior, especially in the Coulomb potential and string tension.
5. **Mass Estimation of Hybrid Mesons**:
- The initial hybrid meson mass estimates are re - examined, and the influence of different calculation methods, such as considering adiabatic surface - mixing effects, is explored.
6. **Decay Model**:
- The flux tube model is extended to describe the decays of mesons and hybrid mesons, different decay mechanisms are proposed, and they are compared with experimental data.
7. **Other Extensions**:
- The application of the flux tube model in glueballs and baryons is discussed, and how to use new accurate lattice data to improve the model is also discussed.
### Summary:
The main purpose of this paper is to evaluate the effectiveness and limitations of the flux tube model in describing low - energy QCD phenomena and to propose directions for improvement and extension. By comparing with the latest lattice gauge theory results and other theoretical models, the author points out the advantages of the model and the areas that need improvement, providing guidance for future theoretical and experimental research.
If you have more specific questions or need further explanations, please feel free to let me know!