Abstract:Confining proteins in synthetic nanoscale spatial compartments has offered a cell-free avenue to understand enzyme structure–function relationships and complex cellular processes near the physiological conditions, an important branch of fundamental protein biophysics studies. Enzyme confinement has also provided advancement in biocatalysis by offering enhanced enzyme reusability, cost-efficiency, and substrate selectivity in certain cases for research and industrial applications. However, the primary research efforts in this area have been focused on the development of novel confinement materials and investigating protein adsorption/interaction with various surfaces, leaving a fundamental knowledge gap, namely, the lack of understanding of the confined enzymes (note that enzyme adsorption to or interactions with surfaces differs from enzyme confinement as the latter offers an enhanced extent of restriction to enzyme movement and/or conformational flexibility). In particular, there is limited understanding of enzymes' structure, dynamics, translocation (into biological pores), folding, and aggregation in extreme cases upon confinement, and how confinement properties such as the size, shape, and rigidity affect these details. The first barrier to bridge this gap is the difficulty in “penetrating” the “shielding” of the confinement walls experimentally; confinement could also lead to high heterogeneity and dynamics in the entrapped enzymes, challenging most protein-probing experimental techniques. The complexity is raised by the variety in the possible confinement environments that enzymes may encounter in nature or on lab benches, which can be categorized to rigid confinement with regular shapes, rigid restriction without regular shapes, and flexible/dynamic confinement which also introduces crowding effects. Thus, to bridge such a knowledge gap, it is critical to combine advanced materials and cutting-edge techniques to re-create the various confinement conditions and understand enzymes therein. We have spearheaded in this challenging area by creating various confinement conditions to restrict enzymes while exploring experimental techniques to understand enzyme behaviors upon confinement at the molecular/residue level. This review is to summarize our key findings on the molecular level details of enzymes confined in (i) rigid compartments with regular shapes based on pre-formed, mesoporous nanoparticles and Metal–Organic Frameworks/Covalent-Organic Frameworks (MOFs/COFs), (ii) rigid confinement with irregular crystal defects with shapes close to the outline of the confined enzymes via co-crystallization of enzymes with certain metal ions and ligands in the aqueous phase (biomineralization), and (iii) flexible, dynamic confinement created by protein-friendly polymeric materials and assemblies. Under each case, we will focus our discussion on (a) the way to load enzymes into the confined spaces, (b) the structural basis of the function and behavior of enzymes within each compartment environments, and (c) technical advances of our methodology to probe the needed structural information. The purposes are to depict the chemical physics details of enzymes at the challenging interface of natural molecules and synthetic compartment materials, guide the selection of enzyme confinement platforms for various applications, and generate excitement in the community on combining cutting-edge technologies and synthetic materials to better understand enzyme performance in biophysics, biocatalysis, and biomedical applications.

Protein crystallization in confined geometries

Conformational Properties and Dynamics of Protein-Like Chains Confined in an Infinite Cylinder

Effects of Surface Structure and Solvophilicity on the Crystallization of Confined Liquids

Molecular confinement influences protein structure and enhances thermal protein stability

Structural Transitions of Confined Model Proteins: Molecular Dynamics Simulation and Experimental Validation

Crystal growth in confinement

Molecular Simulation of Polymer Crystallization under Chain and Space Confinement.

Effects of Confinement on Protein Folding and Protein Stability

Diffusion Control of Homogeneous Crystallization in Nanoconfined Domains of Block Copolymers

Morphological Confinement on Crystallization in Blends of Poly(oxyethylene-<i>b</i><i>lock</i>-oxybutylene) and Poly(oxybutylene)

Monte Carlo study of phase separation in aqueous protein solutions

On the interface of enzyme and spatial confinement: The impacts of confinement rigidity, shape, and surface properties on the interplay of enzyme structure, dynamics, and function

Impact of Confinement within a Hydrogel Mesh on Protein Thermodynamic Stability and Aggregation Kinetics

Molecular Simulations of Confined Crystallization in the Microdomains of Diblock Copolymers

Protein structure, activity and thermal stability within nanoscopic compartments

Molecular simulation of crystallization of polymers confined in cylindrical nanodomain

From adsorption to crystallization of proteins: Evidence for interface-assisted nucleation

Core-Softened colloids under extreme geometrical confinement

Morphology selection kinetics of crystallization in a sphere

Lipidic cubic phase injector facilitates membrane protein serial femtosecond crystallography

A combined approach to extract rotational dynamics of globular proteins undergoing liquid-liquid phase separation