Is Entanglement Monogamous?

Barbara M. Terhal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1147/rd.481.0071

2003-07-17

Abstract:In this article I discuss Charlie's Bennett's influence in quantum information theory and our answers to the question whether quantum entanglement is `monogamous'.

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Should Entanglement Measures be Monogamous or Faithful?

Cécilia Lancien,Sara Di Martino,Marcus Huber,Marco Piani,Gerardo Adesso,Andreas Winter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.117.060501

2016-08-02

Abstract:"Is entanglement monogamous?" asks the title of a popular article [B. Terhal, IBM J. Res. Dev. 48, 71 (2004)], celebrating C. H. Bennett's legacy on quantum information theory. While the answer is affirmative in the qualitative sense, the situation is less clear if monogamy is intended as a quantitative limitation on the distribution of bipartite entanglement in a multipartite system, given some particular measure of entanglement. Here, we formalize what it takes for a bipartite measure of entanglement to obey a general quantitative monogamy relation on all quantum states. We then prove that an important class of entanglement measures fail to be monogamous in this general sense of the term, with monogamy violations becoming generic with increasing dimension. In particular, we show that every additive and suitably normalized entanglement measure cannot satisfy any nontrivial general monogamy relation while at the same time faithfully capturing the geometric entanglement structure of the fully antisymmetric state in arbitrary dimension. Nevertheless, monogamy of such entanglement measures can be recovered if one allows for dimension-dependent relations, as we show explicitly with relevant examples.

Quantum Physics,Statistical Mechanics,High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics
Is monogamy of entanglement geometrical?

X. Dong,H. W. Chen,L. Zhou,H.W. Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1712.04608

2017-12-13

Quantum Physics

Abstract:This work aims to understand the monogamy of quantum entanglement from a geometrical point of view. By regarding quantum entanglement as a geometrical structure on the state space of quantum systems and attributing all entanglement related properties as emergent from this geometry of entanglement, we assume there exists a genuine general monogamous relation of quantum entanglement w.r.t. a correspondent genuine entanglement measure Q* which possesses an underlying geometrical origin. We speculate that the monogamous relations w.r.t. an entanglement measure Q can be understood by comparing the different dimension dependencies of the measure Q and Q*. We gave evidences of our conjecture by readdressing two observed properties of the monogamy relations from this geometrical standpoint. Besides the phenomenal explanation of the monogamy of entanglement, we also discussed a fibre bundle structure based candidate solution for the geometry of entanglement and explained how this idea is related to the ER=EPR conjecture and other interesting quantum information processing problems including monogamy of entanglement, entanglement distillation, bound entanglement and activation, and entanglement catalyst.
Entanglement monogamy in indistinguishable particle systems

Soumya Das,Goutam Paul,Ritabrata Sengupta

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-46515-z

2023-12-11

Abstract:Recently, it has been realized that indistinguishability is a resource for quantum information processing. A new method to represent the indistinguishable particles by Franco et al. (Sci Rep 6:20603, 2016, https://doi.org/10.1038/srep20603 ) and measure the concurrence is developed by Nosrati et al. (npj Quantum Inf 6:39, 2020, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41534-020-0271-7 ). The monogamy property says that quantum entanglement cannot be shared freely between more than two particles. For three distinguishable particles, the monogamy of entanglement was first expressed as an inequality using squared concurrence where each particle has a single degree of freedom (for pure or mixed states). Using multiple degrees of freedom, similar inequality was shown to be held between two distinguishable particles. However, for two indistinguishable particles, where each particle cannot be addressed individually, the monogamy inequality was shown to be violated maximally for a specific state. Thus a question naturally arises: what happens to the monogamy of entanglement in the case of three or more indistinguishable particles? We prove that monogamy holds in this scenario and the inequality becomes equality for all pure indistinguishable states. Further, we provide three major operational meanings of our result. Finally, we present an experimental schematic using photons to observe our result.
Tighter monogamy inequalities of multiqubit entanglement

Jia-Yi Li,Zhong-Xi Shen,Shao-Ming Fei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1612-202X/acf36c

2023-12-15

Abstract:Multipartite entanglement holds great importance in quantum information processing. The distribution of entanglement among subsystems can be characterized by monogamy relations. Based on the $\beta$th power of concurrence and negativity, we provide two new monogamy inequalities. Through detailed examples, we demonstrate that these inequalities are tighter than previous results.

Quantum Physics
The Fate of Entanglement

Gilles Parez,William Witczak-Krempa

2024-06-28

Abstract:Quantum entanglement is a fundamentally non-local correlation between particles. In its simplest realisation, a measurement on one particle is affected by a prior measurement on its partner, irrespective of their separation. For multiple particles, purely collective types of entanglement exist but their detection, even theoretically, remains an outstanding open question. Here, we show that all forms of multipartite entanglement entirely disappear during the typical evolution of a system as it heats up, evolves in time, or as its parts become separated. These results follow from the nature of the entanglement-free continent in the space of physical states, and hold in great generality. We illustrate these phenomena with a frustrated molecular quantum magnet in and out of equilibrium. In contrast, if the particles are fermions, such as electrons, another notion of entanglement exists that protects bipartite quantum correlations. However, truly collective fermionic entanglement disappears during typical evolution, thus sharing the same fate as in bosonic systems. These findings provide fundamental knowledge about the structure of entanglement in quantum matter and architectures, paving the way for its manipulation.

Quantum Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons,High Energy Physics - Theory
Multipartite Monogamy of Entanglement for Three Qubit States

Priyabrata Char,Dipayan Chakraborty,Prabir Kumar Dey,Ajoy Sen,Amit Bhar,Indrani Chattopadhyay,Debasis Sarkar

2024-09-02

Abstract:The distribution of entanglement in a multiparty system can be described through the principles of monogamy or polygamy. Monogamy is a fundamental characteristic of entanglement that restricts its distribution among several number of parties(more than two). In this work, our aim is to explore how quantum entanglement can be distributed in accordance with monogamy relations by utilizing both the genuine multipartite entanglement measures and bipartite entanglement measures. Specifically, we treat source entanglement as the genuine multipartite entanglement measure and use the entanglement of formation specifically for bipartite cases. For GHZ class states, we analytically demonstrate that the square of the source entanglement serves as an upper bound for the sum of the squares of the entanglement of formation of the reduced subsystems, with some exceptions for specific non-generic GHZ states. We also present numerical evidence supporting this result for W class states. Additionally, we explore the monogamy relation by using accessible entanglement as an upper bound.

Quantum Physics
General monogamy relations of the $S^{t}$ and $T^{t}_q$-entropy entanglement measures based on dual entropy

Zhong-Xi Shen,Kang-Kang Yang,Zhi-Xiang Jin,Zhi-Xi Wang,Shao-Ming Fei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11128-024-04481-z

2024-07-18

Abstract:Monogamy of entanglement is the fundamental property of quantum systems. By using two new entanglement measures based on dual entropy, the $S^{t}$-entropy entanglement and $T^{t}_q$-entropy entanglement measures, we present the general monogamy relations in multi-qubit quantum systems. We show that these newly derived monogamy inequalities are tighter than the existing ones. Based on these general monogamy relations, we construct the set of multipartite entanglement indicators for $N$-qubit states, which are shown to work well even for the cases that the usual concurrence-based indicators do not work. Detailed examples are presented to illustrate our results.

Quantum Physics
Entanglement Monogamy in a Three-Qubit State

Jie-Hui Huang,Shi-Yao Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreva.78.012325

IF: 2.971

2008-01-01

Physical Review A

Abstract:We investigate the monogamy nature of entanglement in a three-qubit system. A monogamy inequality is presented to describe the exclusive relation between the A-B two-qubit concurrence CAB and the AB-C threequbit concurrence C AB C, which represents the entanglement between qubits A and B as a whole and the third qubit C. It is found that the entanglement between any two qubits in a three-qubit system is limited by the entanglement between these two qubits and another qubit. As a consequence, we present the upper bounds for the concurrence CAB, when the concurrence between qubits A and C CAC and the concurrence between qubits B and C CBC are both given or one of the two is provided.
Detecting Quantum Entanglement

Barbara M. Terhal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0101032

2001-01-09

Abstract:We review the criteria for separability and quantum entanglement, both in a bipartite as well as a multipartite setting. We discuss Bell inequalities, entanglement witnesses, entropic inequalities, bound entanglement and several features of multipartite entanglement. We indicate how these criteria bear on the experimental detection of quantum entanglement.

Quantum Physics
Monogamy inequality in terms of entanglement measures based on distance for pure multiqubit states

Limin Gao,Fengli Yan,Ting Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10773-020-04564-4

2020-05-01

Abstract:Using very general arguments, we prove that any entanglement measures based on distance must be maximal on pure states. Furthermore, we show that Bures measure of entanglement and geometric measure of entanglement satisfy the monogamy inequality on all pure multiqubit states. Finally, using the power of Bures measure of entanglement and geometric measure of entanglement, we present a class of tight monogamy relations for pure states of multiqubit systems.

Quantum Physics
General polygamy inequality of multi-party quantum entanglement

Jeong San Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1202.2184

2012-02-10

Quantum Physics

Abstract:Using entanglement of assistance, we establish a general polygamy inequality of multi-party entanglement in arbitrary dimensional quantum systems. For multi-party closed quantum systems, we relate our result with the monogamy of entanglement to show that the entropy of entanglement is an universal entanglement measure that bounds both monogamy and polygamy of multi-party quantum entanglement.
Entanglement Monogamy via Multivariate Trace Inequalities

Mario Berta,Marco Tomamichel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00220-023-04920-5

IF: 2.361

2024-02-02

Communications in Mathematical Physics

Abstract:Entropy is a fundamental concept in quantum information theory that allows to quantify entanglement and investigate its properties, for example its monogamy over multipartite systems. Here, we derive variational formulas for relative entropies based on restricted measurements of multipartite quantum systems. By combining these with multivariate matrix trace inequalities, we recover and sometimes strengthen various existing entanglement monogamy inequalities. In particular, we give direct, matrix-analysis-based proofs for the faithfulness of squashed entanglement by relating it to the relative entropy of entanglement measured with one-way local operations and classical communication, as well as for the faithfulness of conditional entanglement of mutual information by relating it to the separably measured relative entropy of entanglement. We discuss variations of these results using the relative entropy to states with positive partial transpose, and multipartite setups. Our results simplify and generalize previous derivations in the literature that employed operational arguments about the asymptotic achievability of information-theoretic tasks.

physics, mathematical
Rényi relative entropy based monogamy of entanglement in tripartite systems

Marwa Mannaï,Hisham Sati,Tim Byrnes,Chandrashekar Radhakrishnan

2024-11-04

Abstract:A comprehensive investigation of the entanglement characteristics is carried out on tripartite spin-1/2 systems, examining prototypical tripartite states, the thermal Heisenberg model, and the transverse field Ising model. The entanglement is computed using the Rényi relative entropy. In the traditional Rényi relative entropy, the generalization parameter $\alpha$ can take values only in the range $0 \leq \alpha \leq 2$ due to the requirements of joint convexity of the measure. To use the Rényi relative entropy over a wider range of $\alpha$, we use the sandwiched form which is jointly convex in the regime $0.5 \leq \alpha \leq \infty$. In prototypical tripartite states, we find that GHZ states are monogamous, but surprisingly so are W states. On the other hand, star states exhibit polygamy, due to the higher level of purity of the bipartite subsystems. For spin models, we study the dependence of entanglement on various parameters such as temperature, spin-spin interaction, and anisotropy, and identify regions where entanglement is the largest. The Rényi parameter $\alpha$ scales the amount of entanglement in the system. The entanglement measure based on the traditional and the sandwiched Rényi relative entropies obey the Araki-Lieb-Thirring inequality. In the Heisenberg models, namely the XYZ, XXZ, and XY models, the system is always monogamous. However, in the transverse field Ising model, the state is initially polygamous and becomes monogamous with temperature and coupling.

Quantum Physics
The social aspects of quantum entanglement

Gerardo Adesso

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0706.0286

2007-06-02

Popular Physics

Abstract:This brief article discusses some aspects of quantum theory and their impact on popular culture. The basic features of quantum entanglement between two or more parties are introduced in a language suitable for a general audience, and metaphorically connected to love and faithfulness in human relationships.
Monogamy of nonconvex entanglement measures

Li-Min Gao,Feng-Li Yan,Ting Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rinp.2021.104983

IF: 4.565

2021-12-01

Results in Physics

Abstract:One of the fundamental traits of quantum entanglement is the restricted shareability among multipartite quantum systems, namely monogamy of entanglement, while it is well known that monogamy inequalities are always satisfied by entanglement measures with convexity. Here we present a measure of entanglement, logarithmic convex-roof extended negativity (LCREN) satisfying important characteristics of an entanglement measure, and investigate the monogamy relation for logarithmic negativity and LCREN both without convexity. We show exactly that the α th power of logarithmic negativity, and a newly defined good measure of entanglement, LCREN, obey a class of general monogamy inequalities in multiqubit systems, 2 ⊗ 2 ⊗ 3 systems and 2 ⊗ 2 ⊗ 2 n systems for α ≥ 4 ln 2 . We provide a class of general polygamy inequalities of multiqubit systems in terms of logarithmic convex-roof extended negativity of assistance (LCRENoA) for 0 ≤ β ≤ 2 . Given that the logarithmic negativity and LCREN are not convex, these results are surprising. Using the power of the logarithmic negativity and LCREN, we further establish a class of tight monogamy inequalities of multiqubit systems, 2 ⊗ 2 ⊗ 3 systems and 2 ⊗ 2 ⊗ 2 n systems in terms of the α th power of logarithmic negativity and LCREN for α ≥ 4 ln 2 . We also show that the β th power of LCRENoA obeys a class of tight polygamy inequalities of multiqubit systems for 0 ≤ β ≤ 2 .

physics, multidisciplinary,materials science
Strong monogamy of quantum entanglement for multi-qubit W-class states

Jeong San Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1411.4721

2014-11-18

Quantum Physics

Abstract:We provide a strong evidence for strong monogamy inequality of multi-qubit entanglement recently proposed in [B. Regula {\em et al.}, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 113}, 110501 (2014)]. We consider a large class of multi-qubit generalized W-class states, and analytically show that the strong monogamy inequality of multi-qubit entanglement is saturated by this class of states.
Entanglement and Nonlocality in Multi-Particle Systems

Margaret D. Reid,Qiong-Yi He,Peter D. Drummond

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11467-011-0233-9

2012-01-01

Frontiers of Physics

Abstract:Entanglement, the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox and Bell’s failure of local-hiddenvariable (LHV) theories are three historically famous forms of “quantum nonlocality”. We give experimental criteria for these three forms of nonlocality in multi-particle systems, with the aim of better understanding the transition from microscopic to macroscopic nonlocality. We examine the nonlocality of N separated spin J systems. First, we obtain multipartite Bell inequalities that address the correlation between spin values measured at each site, and then we review spin squeezing inequalities that address the degree of reduction in the variance of collective spins. The latter have been particularly useful as a tool for investigating entanglement in Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC). We present solutions for two topical quantum states: multi-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, and the ground state of a two-well BEC.
Everything is entangled in quantum mechanics: on the measures of quantum entanglement

Christian de Ronde,Raimundo Fernández Mouján,César Massri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epjp/s13360-024-05824-6

2024-11-30

The European Physical Journal Plus

Abstract:Even though quantum entanglement is today's most essential concept within the new technological era of quantum information processing, we do not only lack a consistent definition of this kernel notion, we are also far from understanding its physical meaning [1]. These failures have led to many problems when attempting to provide a consistent measure or quantification of entanglement. In fact, the two main lines of contemporary research within the orthodox literature have created mazes where inconsistencies and problems are found everywhere. While the operational-instrumentalist approach has failed to explain how inequalities are able to distinguish the classical from the quantum, the geometrical approach has failed to provide a consistent meaningful account of their entropic measure. Taking distance from orthodoxy, in this work, we address the quantification and measure of quantum entanglement by considering a recently presented objective-invariant definition in terms of the coding of intensive relations [2] which allows to escape the widespread relativist account of bases and factorizations [3, 4]. Going beyond the orthodox dualistic reference to "quantum particles" and "clicks" in detectors, we will argue that this new line of research is capable not only to evade the many open problems which appear within the mainstream literature, but is also able to present a consistent and coherent physical understanding of entanglement. The main conclusion of this work is that in quantum mechanics—contrary to what is generally presupposed—all operational expressions found within the laboratory are intrinsically entangled.

physics, multidisciplinary
Stronger Monogamy Relations of Fidelity Based Entanglement Measures in Multiqubit Systems

Zhong-Xi Shen,Kang-Kang Yang,Yu Lu,Zhi-Xi Wang,Shao-Ming Fei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10773-024-05677-w

2024-05-28

International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Abstract:Monogamy of entanglement is the fundamental property and inherent nature of quantum systems. We study the monogamy properties of two fidelity based entanglement measures, the Bures measure of entanglement and the geometric measure of entanglement. Stronger monogamy relations are presented for the th ( ) power and the th ( ) power of these two entanglement measures. Moreover, for the case of the th ( ) power, we give the corresponding upper bounds for the two entanglement measures. Detailed examples are provided to illustrate that our newly established monogamy relations are stronger than the previous ones.

physics, multidisciplinary

Is Entanglement Monogamous?

Should Entanglement Measures be Monogamous or Faithful?

Is monogamy of entanglement geometrical?

Entanglement monogamy in indistinguishable particle systems

Tighter monogamy inequalities of multiqubit entanglement

The Fate of Entanglement

Multipartite Monogamy of Entanglement for Three Qubit States

General monogamy relations of the $S^{t}$ and $T^{t}_q$-entropy entanglement measures based on dual entropy

Entanglement Monogamy in a Three-Qubit State

Detecting Quantum Entanglement

Monogamy inequality in terms of entanglement measures based on distance for pure multiqubit states

General polygamy inequality of multi-party quantum entanglement

Entanglement Monogamy via Multivariate Trace Inequalities

Rényi relative entropy based monogamy of entanglement in tripartite systems

The social aspects of quantum entanglement

Monogamy of nonconvex entanglement measures

Strong monogamy of quantum entanglement for multi-qubit W-class states

Entanglement and Nonlocality in Multi-Particle Systems

Everything is entangled in quantum mechanics: on the measures of quantum entanglement

Stronger Monogamy Relations of Fidelity Based Entanglement Measures in Multiqubit Systems