James A. R. Marshall
Abstract:The 2 x 2 games, in particular the Prisoner's Dilemma, have been extensively used in studies into reciprocal cooperation and, to a lesser extent, kin selection. This paper examines the suitability of the 2 x 2 games for modelling the evolution of cooperation through reciprocation and kin selection. This examination is not restricted to the Prisoner's Dilemma, but includes the other non-trivial symmetric 2 x 2 games. We show that the popularity of the Prisoner's Dilemma for modelling social and biotic interaction is justified by its superiority according to these criteria. Indeed, the Prisoner's Dilemma is unique in providing the simplest support for reciprocal cooperation, and additive kin-selected altruism. However, care is still required in choosing the particular Prisoner's Dilemma payoff matrix to use. This paper reviews the impact of non-linear payoffs for the application of Hamilton's rule to typical altruistic interactions, and derives new results for cases in which the roles of potential altruist and beneficiary are separated. In doing so we find the same equilibrium condition holds in continuous games between relatives, and in discrete games with roles.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the applicability of 2x2 games (especially the Prisoner's Dilemma) in studying reciprocal cooperation and kin selection. Specifically, the author James A. R. Marshall explores the following two key issues:
1. **Modeling Reciprocal Cooperation**: The author evaluates whether 2x2 games are suitable for modeling cooperation that has evolved through reciprocal behavior. Reciprocal cooperation refers to the situation where individuals adjust their own behaviors based on the past behaviors of others through repeated interactions, thereby achieving mutually beneficial cooperation.
2. **Modeling Kin Selection**: The author examines whether 2x2 games are suitable for modeling altruistic behaviors that have evolved through kin selection. The kin selection theory holds that if an altruistic behavior is beneficial to relatives carrying the same genes, then this behavior can spread in the population.
### Main Findings
- **Unique Advantages of the Prisoner's Dilemma**: The author points out that the Prisoner's Dilemma is the most suitable model in 2x2 games for studying reciprocal cooperation and kin selection. It provides the simplest framework that supports reciprocal cooperation and can well simulate the altruistic behaviors of additive kin selection.
- **The Influence of Non - linear Payoffs**: The author discusses the influence of non - linear payoffs on Hamilton's rule (used to judge whether altruistic behaviors are advantageous). When the payoffs are non - linear, special attention needs to be paid to selecting an appropriate Prisoner's Dilemma payoff matrix to ensure the accuracy of the model.
- **The Situation of Role Separation**: The author also analyzes that in some cases, the roles of potential altruists and beneficiaries are separated, which will affect the selection of altruistic behaviors. For example, in continuous games or discrete games with clear role divisions, the same equilibrium conditions still hold.
### Conclusion
Although the Prisoner's Dilemma is the most commonly used 2x2 game model, it is still necessary to carefully select the specific payoff matrix when applying it. In addition, the author emphasizes the influence of non - linear payoffs on the modeling of altruistic behaviors and presents new insights in the situation of role separation. These findings are helpful for better understanding how to use 2x2 games to study reciprocal cooperation and kin selection.
### Related Formulas
- **Hamilton's Rule**:
\[
r \cdot b>c
\]
where \(r\) is the coefficient of kinship, \(b\) is the fitness gain brought to the recipient by the altruistic behavior, and \(c\) is the fitness loss brought to the donor by the altruistic behavior.
- **Definition of Synergistic Effect**:
\[
d=(A + D)-(B + C)
\]
where \(A, B, C, D\) are the payoff values in the 2x2 game respectively, and \(d\) represents the synergistic effect when two altruists interact.
- **Correlation Threshold**:
\[
r'=\frac{(R - S)-f_c(S - P + T - R)}{T - P}
\]
where \(r'\) is the lowest correlation threshold for the selection of altruistic behaviors, and \(f_c\) is the frequency of the cooperative allele in the population.
Through these analyses, the author provides important guidance for future research, especially in terms of selecting appropriate game models and parameters.