The evolution of radiation towards thermal equilibrium: A soluble model which illustrates the foundations of Statistical Mechanics

Michael Nauenberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1632488

2003-05-10

Abstract:In 1916 Einstein introduced the first rules for a quantum theory of electromagnetic radiation, and he applied them to a model of matter in thermal equilibrium with radiation to derive Planck's black-body formula. Einstein's treatment is extended here to time-dependent stochastic variables, which leads to a master equation for the probability distribution that describes the irreversible approach of Einstein's model towards thermal equilibrium, and elucidates aspects of the foundation of statistical mechanics. An analytic solution of this equation is obtained in the Fokker-Planck approximation which is in excellent agreement with numerical results. At equilibrium, it is shown that the probability distribution is proportional to the total number of microstates for a given configuration, in accordance with Boltzmann's fundamental postulate of equal a priori probabilities for these states. While the counting of these configurations depends on particle statistics- Boltzmann, Bose-Einstein, or Fermi-Dirac - the corresponding probability is determined here by the dynamics which are embodied in the form of Einstein's quantum transition probabilities for the emission and absorption of radiation. In a special limit, it is shown that the photons in Einstein's model can act as a thermal bath for the evolution of the atoms towards the canonical equilibrium distribution of Gibbs. In this limit, the present model is mathematically equivalent to an extended version of the Ehrenfests' ``dog-flea'' model, which has been discussed recently by Ambegaokar and Clerk.

Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Why do the black - body radiation formulas derived by Einstein and Boltzmann based on different assumptions yield the same result? Specifically, the paper explores explaining this phenomenon by introducing random variables to deal with the Einstein model and shows how to understand the foundations of statistical mechanics from a kinetic perspective.

### Core problems of the paper
1. **Unifying different derivation methods**:
- In 1877, Boltzmann proposed the basic principle of statistical mechanics, that is, in thermal equilibrium, the microscopic states of an isolated system with the same total energy occur with equal a priori probabilities.
- In 1900, Planck derived the black - body radiation formula based on the quantum hypothesis.
- In 1916, Einstein proposed the quantum theory of photon emission and absorption and derived Planck's black - body radiation formula through detailed balance arguments.

2. **Explaining the consistency**:
- Although Einstein and Boltzmann's methods are different, they both obtained the same black - body radiation formula. The paper attempts to explain this consistency.

3. **Introducing random variables**:
- By regarding the variables in the Einstein model as time - dependent random variables, the paper derives the master equation (master equation) of the probability distribution that describes the system's irreversible tendency towards thermal equilibrium.
- Under the Fokker - Planck approximation, an analytical solution is obtained and compared with numerical results.

4. **Foundations of statistical mechanics**:
- The paper shows that in thermal equilibrium, the probability distribution is proportional to the total number of microscopic states of a given configuration in the system, which is in line with Boltzmann's basic assumption.
- The number of these configurations is calculated through particle statistics (Boltzmann, Bose - Einstein or Fermi - Dirac), but the corresponding probabilities are determined by Einstein's quantum transition probabilities.

### Specific problem solutions
- **Why do two different derivation methods lead to the same result?**
- By considering the random treatment of the Einstein model, the paper shows that the probability distribution obtained in thermal equilibrium is consistent with the application of Boltzmann's a priori probability assumption.
- Einstein's transition probabilities (including spontaneous emission and stimulated transitions) determine the kinetic process of the system tending towards thermal equilibrium.

- **How to describe the process of the system tending towards thermal equilibrium?**
- The paper derives a time - dependent master equation that describes the irreversible process of radiation and matter tending towards thermal equilibrium.
- Under the Fokker - Planck approximation, an analytical solution in Gaussian form is obtained, and its mean and width parameters are highly consistent with the numerical results.

In summary, this paper aims to explain the consistency of different derivation methods by introducing random variables to deal with the Einstein model and further explore the fundamental problems of statistical mechanics.