Testing braneworlds with the binary pulsar

Ruth Durrer,Philippe Kocian
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0264-9381/21/8/015
2004-04-30
Abstract:In this letter we calculate the emission of gravity waves by the binary pulsar in the framework of five dimensional braneworlds. We consider only spacetimes with one compact extra-dimension. We show that the presence of additional degrees of freedom, especially the 'gravi-scalar' leads to a modification of Einstein's quadrupole formula. We compute the induced change for the binary pulsar PSR 1913+16 where it amounts to about 20% which is by far excluded by present experimental data.
High Energy Physics - Theory,Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to test the existence of extra dimensions through binary pulsars. Specifically, the authors calculated the emission of gravitational waves within the framework of five - dimensional space - time and focused on the space - time containing only one compact extra dimension. They pointed out that the existence of extra degrees of freedom (especially the "gravitational scalar" or "gravi - scalar") would lead to a modification of Einstein's quadrupole formula. ### Main problems 1. **Influence of extra dimensions**: To study whether the emission of gravitational waves in five - dimensional space - time is consistent with the observational data. 2. **Modifying Einstein's quadrupole formula**: To explore the influence of new degrees of freedom (such as the gravitational scalar) introduced by extra dimensions on the emission of gravitational waves. 3. **Experimental verification**: To verify these theoretical predictions through the data of the binary pulsar PSR 1913 + 16. ### Research background In recent years, scientists have proposed the view that the 3 + 1 - dimensional universe we live in may be a hypersurface in a higher - dimensional space - time. This possibility can be explained by assuming that only gravitational interactions propagate in the complete space - time, while gauge interactions are restricted to the 3 + 1 - dimensional "brane". This theory can provide new ideas for solving the hierarchy problem. ### Research methods - **Five - dimensional linear perturbation theory**: Use the five - dimensional linear perturbation Einstein equations to derive the modified gravitational wave emission formula. - **Binary system model**: Take the binary pulsar PSR 1913 + 16 as an example to calculate the energy loss of its gravitational wave emission. - **Comparison and verification**: Compare the theoretically predicted results with the experimental observational data to verify whether there are significant deviations. ### Key results The authors found that, considering the compact extra dimension, the five - dimensional linear perturbation Einstein equations are in conflict with the observational data. Specifically, for PSR 1913 + 16, the modified energy loss is about 20% of the standard quadrupole formula, which is inconsistent with the experimental observational results (with an error within 0.5%). ### Conclusions The paper concludes that if the extra dimensions are compact and the five - dimensional Einstein equations can produce a normalizable zero - mode, then non - gravitational interactions must be involved to make the model consistent with the observations. For example, it is necessary to assign a mass to the gravitational scalar so that it cannot be excited by the binary pulsar. In addition, for models with more extra dimensions, the problem may be more complicated because multiple gravitational scalars may jointly contribute similar gravitational wave emission effects. ### Formula display The key formulas involved in the paper include: - Quadrupole formula modification term: \[ -\left(\frac{dE}{dt}\right)_{\text{scalar}}=\frac{21G_4}{8}\left[\frac{d^3}{dt^3}\int\rho x^2d^3x\right]^2 \] - Average energy loss of binary system: \[ -\left\langle\frac{dE}{dt}\right\rangle=\frac{21G_4}{4M_1M_2(M_1 + M_2)}g(e)\frac{1}{a^5(1 - e^2)^{7/2}} \] where \(g(e)=e^2(1 + e^2)\). Through these formulas and analyses, the authors show the specific influence of extra dimensions on the emission of gravitational waves and point out the inconsistency with the existing observational data.