Michael B. Partensky
Abstract:A simple two charge system, one charge being suspended on a spring, exhibits complex behavior including bistability, hysteresis and catastrophic response to gradual variation of the external parameters. We discuss these complex features (that can be related, e.g., to membrane electroporation and voltage gating of ion channels) using only high school physics. Similar properties are displayed by a system comprised of magnets and springs. Using this analogy, a simple demonstration model was designed in collaboration with John Griffin, using components of the "Rogers Connections" magnetic construction toy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how the equilibrium behavior between a spring and an electric charge responds non - linearly to small changes in external conditions under specific conditions. Specifically, the author uses a simple physical model to explain why in some cases, the equilibrium state of the system responds abruptly to the gradual change of external conditions instead of a smooth change.
### Problem Background
The paper mentions that usually, the system will have a correspondingly small - scale response to a small - scale change in external conditions. For example, a slight increase in the force on a spring will lead to a slight increase in its elongation, or a small increase in altitude will only cause a tiny change in air pressure. This kind of behavior can be considered "normal".
However, in real life, in many cases, the behavior of the system is not like this. For example:
- Increasing the load on a branch may cause it to break suddenly;
- A gradual decrease in temperature will cause water to change suddenly from a liquid to a solid;
- When crossing Cape Cod, even though the distance is short, the sea water temperature will change abruptly from warm to cold.
These phenomena require complex physical and mathematical theories to explain, but they can also be discussed with simple high - school physics knowledge.
### Specific Problem Description
The specific problem in the paper is about the interaction between two electric charges (Q and q) and between q and a spring. The position and value of Q are fixed, while q can move and is attached to a spring with a stiffness coefficient of Γ. When the value of q changes, the researchers hope to find the new equilibrium position \( l \) and verify the stability of this equilibrium position.
#### Mathematical Model
According to Coulomb's law and Hooke's law, the equilibrium condition of the system can be expressed as:
\[
0=\frac{Qq}{l^{2}}-\Gamma(l - l_{0})
\]
Introducing the dimensionless distance \( z = \frac{l}{l_{0}} \) and defining the parameter \( \gamma=\frac{\Gamma l_{0}^{3}}{kQ} \), the equation can be rewritten as:
\[
\gamma qz=z^{2}-1
\]
Further analysis reveals that for negative charge q, there are some unusual phenomena: as q increases (becomes more negative), the equilibrium position does not always change continuously, but there are multiple possible equilibrium points, and some equilibrium points are unstable.
### Challenge Problems
The paper also proposes two challenge problems:
1. If the two electric charges are surrounded by hard shells with a finite radius, limiting their closest distance to \( z_{\text{min}} \), how does the equilibrium property of the system depend on \( z_{\text{min}} \)?
2. How does an externally applied uniform electric field affect the equilibrium behavior of the system?
### Conclusion
Through analysis and illustration, the author shows that under certain conditions, the system will produce a significant non - linear response to small changes in external conditions, which is similar to phase - change, bifurcation and catastrophe phenomena. Although these problems are complex, they can be preliminarily explored with simple high - school physics knowledge, which helps students understand the behavior of non - linear systems and their potential applications, such as biophysical phenomena like voltage - gated ion channels.
In general, this paper aims to reveal complex physical phenomena through simple models and guide readers to think about the abrupt behavior in non - linear systems.