What is osmosis? Explanation and understanding of a physical phenomenon

Frank G. Borg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0305011

2003-05-06

Abstract:Although osmosis is a familiar phenomenon, and of pivotal importance in natural systems, it is seldom explained how it might work on the molecular level (if treated at all in physics text books). The standard treatment of osmosis in thermodynamics employs the concept of the chemical potential and does not give any clues how the process "really" works. On the other hand one may also encounter conflicting qualitative and molecular explanations of osmosis. We use the case of osmosis in the present paper to elucidate different ways to "explain" and "understand" physical phenomena. The role of qualitative understanding of physical phenomena is emphasized. However, as the case of osmosis demonstrates, there may be a big gap between the abstract macroscopic theory and molecular conceptions of the mechanism.

General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of understanding of the molecular mechanism of osmosis. Specifically, although the osmosis phenomenon is very important and widely known in nature, it is rarely explained in detail at the molecular level in physics textbooks. The traditional thermodynamic treatment mainly relies on the concept of chemical potential and does not provide clues as to how the process "really" occurs. Therefore, this paper aims to elucidate the osmosis phenomenon through different explanatory methods, especially from the micro and macro levels.

### Main problems

1. **Limitations of the traditional thermodynamic explanation**:
- The traditional explanation of the osmosis phenomenon is based on the concept of chemical potential in thermodynamics, but this method fails to provide an intuitive understanding of the molecular mechanism.
- Many students have difficulty understanding the actual process when studying these abstract thermodynamic formulas and may even have the misunderstanding of some mysterious "osmotic force".

2. **Lack of understanding at the molecular level**:
- Although thermodynamics can predict the osmotic effect, it cannot explain the specific mechanism of this effect, especially at the molecular level.
- Traditional thermodynamics mainly focuses on the equilibrium state rather than the transition process from one state to another.

3. **Comparison of different explanatory methods**:
- The paper explores different types of explanations (such as mechanistic theory, surface theory, solute - attraction theory, etc.) and attempts to bridge the gap between theory and the actual mechanism.
- It emphasizes the importance of qualitative understanding, that is, not only mathematical derivations are required, but also the principles behind physical phenomena need to be intuitively understood.

### Solutions

- **Introducing multiple explanatory models**: The paper uses different theoretical models (such as mechanistic theory, surface theory, solute - attraction theory, etc.) to explain the osmosis phenomenon, helping readers better understand the mechanism at the molecular level.
- **Combining thermodynamics and molecular dynamics**: By combining the abstract formulas of thermodynamics with the specific mechanisms of molecular dynamics, a more comprehensive understanding is provided.
- **Emphasizing qualitative understanding**: Readers are encouraged not only to rely on mathematical formulas but also to understand complex physical phenomena through simple physical models and intuitive images.

### Formula explanation

The classical formula for osmotic pressure is:
\[ \Pi = kTc \]
where:
- \(\Pi\) is the osmotic pressure,
- \(k\) is the Boltzmann constant,
- \(T\) is the absolute temperature,
- \(c\) is the solute concentration (the number of solute particles per unit volume).

This formula predicts that at 20 °C, a solute concentration of 1 mole/liter will produce a pressure of approximately 25 atmospheres.

Through these methods, the paper hopes to fill the gap between the traditional thermodynamic explanation and the understanding of the molecular mechanism and provide a more comprehensive and intuitive explanation of the osmosis phenomenon.