Swift Pointing and the Association Between Gamma-Ray Bursts and Gravitational-Wave Bursts

Lee Samuel Finn,Badri Krishnan,Patrick J. Sutton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/383257

2003-04-12

Abstract:The currently accepted model for gamma-ray burst phenomena involves the violent formation of a rapidly rotating solar mass black hole. Gravitational waves should be associated with the black-hole formation, and their detection would permit this model to be tested, the black hole progenitor (e.g., coalescing binary or collapsing stellar core) identified, and the origin of the gamma rays (within the expanding relativistic fireball or at the point of impact on the interstellar medium) located. Even upper limits on the gravitational-wave strength associated with gamma-ray bursts could constrain the gamma-ray burst model. To do any of these requires joint observations of gamma-ray burst events with gravitational and gamma-ray detectors. Here we examine how the quality of an upper limit on the gravitational-wave strength associated with gamma-ray burst observations depends on the relative orientation of the gamma-ray-burst and gravitational-wave detectors, and apply our results to the particular case of the Swift Burst-Alert Telescope (BAT) and the LIGO gravitational-wave detectors. A result of this investigation is a science-based ``figure of merit'' that can be used, together with other mission constraints, to optimize the pointing of the Swift telescope for the detection of gravitational waves associated with gamma-ray bursts.

Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to test the current models regarding gamma - ray burst (GRB) phenomena and determine whether gravitational waves are generated during the formation of black holes by jointly observing gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts (GWB). Specifically, the author explored the correlation between gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts and proposed a method to optimize the pointing of the Swift satellite to improve the sensitivity of joint observations of gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts.

### Detailed Interpretation

1. **Research Background**:
- The currently accepted gamma - ray burst model holds that gamma - ray bursts are caused by the violent formation of a rapidly rotating black hole with a mass approximately that of the sun.
- Gravitational waves should be generated during the formation of black holes. The detection of these gravitational waves can verify the model, identify the black - hole progenitor (such as binary mergers or stellar core collapses), and locate the origin of gamma - rays (inside the expanding relativistic fireball or at the impact point in the interstellar medium).

2. **Core of the Problem**:
- Even an upper - limit estimate of the gravitational - wave intensity can constrain the gamma - ray burst model.
- The key lies in how to test the above - mentioned model and obtain more detailed information by jointly observing gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts.

3. **Research Methods**:
- The author used the LIGO gravitational - wave detector and the Burst - Alert Telescope (BAT) on the Swift satellite for joint observations.
- They analyzed the correlation between gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts in different directions and proposed a "figure of merit" to evaluate the impact of different satellite pointings on the observational sensitivity.

4. **Main Results**:
- By optimizing the pointing of the Swift satellite, the upper - limit estimate of the gravitational - wave intensity can be reduced by a factor of 2 in some cases.
- This figure of merit can serve as an important indicator for mission planning, helping to optimize the Swift satellite's observation strategy to maximize the sensitivity of joint observations.

5. **Conclusion**:
- Optimizing the pointing of the Swift satellite can significantly improve the detection ability of gravitational - wave signals in the gamma - ray burst system without endangering other mission objectives.
- This optimization is of great significance for a more in - depth understanding of the gamma - ray burst mechanism and gravitational - wave characteristics in the future.

### Formula Summary
The main formulas involved in the paper include:

- The expression of the gravitational - wave signal:
\[
h_i(t) = h_{ab}(t, \vec{x}_i) d^i_{ab}
\]
where \(d^i_{ab}=\frac{1}{2}(\hat{X}^i_a\hat{X}^i_b - \hat{Y}^i_a\hat{Y}^i_b)\) is the direction tensor of the interferometer arms.

- The definition of the cross - correlation statistic \(S(\hat{\Omega}_k, \tau_k)\):
\[
S(\hat{\Omega}_k, \tau_k)=\int_0^T dt\int_0^T dt' s_1(t_k^{(1)} - t)Q(t - t')s_2(t_k^{(2)} - t')
\]

- The average value of the gravitational - wave contribution:
\[
\langle h_1, h_2\rangle=\rho_{\text{GWB}}(\hat{\Omega}|d_1, d_2)\int_0^T dt\int_0^T dt' Q(t - t')h_+(t)h_+(t')
\]
where \(\rho_{\text{GWB}}(\hat{\Omega}|d_1, d_2)=\sum_{A = +,\times}(d_1:\epsilon_A(\hat{\Omega}))(d_2:\epsilon_A(\hat{\Omega}))\) describes the sensitivity of the gravitational - wave detector to gravitational waves from different directions.

These formulas show how the author optimizes the joint observation of gamma - ray bursts and gravitational - wave bursts through mathematical models and physical principles.