Compositional analyses of a Reutlingen Bronze Age sword discovered at Giurgiu, Romania

Agata Olariu,Emilian Alexandrescu,Alexandru Avram,Teodor Badica
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0304058
2003-04-17
Abstract:The compositional scheme of a Bronze Age sword, found near the town of Giurgiu in Romania has been determined by the method of particle-induced X-ray emission (PIXE), at the tandem accelerator of the National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering from Bucharest, Magurele, Romania. The results of the analyses and the comparison with the composition of other swords from the same geographic area, the Danubian plane from Bulgaria and Transylvania regions, show that the sword from Giurgiu could be relatively associated with the swords from Bulgaria, having also the same stylistic, temporal and geographical similitude.
Physics and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to analyze the composition of a Bronze - Age sword found near Giurgiu, Romania, through Particle - Induced X - ray Emission (PIXE) technology, and compare its composition with that of other swords from the same geographical area, such as Bulgaria and Transylvania. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Determine the composition of the sword**: Use PIXE technology to analyze the elemental composition of the Giurgiu sword, especially the contents of elements such as arsenic (As), cobalt (Co), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), nickel (Ni), tin (Sn) and zinc (Zn). 2. **Compare the similarity of composition**: Compare the composition of the Giurgiu sword with other Bronze - Age swords from Bulgaria and Transylvania to explore the similarities and differences in composition among these swords. 3. **Archaeological association**: By combining composition analysis and archaeological background, determine the similarities in time, geography and style between the Giurgiu sword and other swords, so as to infer its possible origin and age. ### Main conclusions According to the results of composition analysis, the composition of the Giurgiu sword is relatively close to that of the Bulgarian swords, especially showing similarities in the contents of arsenic (As), copper (Cu) and tin (Sn). Based on these similarities and archaeological evidence, the researchers believe that the Giurgiu sword may belong to the end of the 13th century BC (around 1200 BC) and is closely related to the Reutlingen - type swords. In addition, the study also points out that the Giurgiu sword is smaller in size, so it is more like a "Kurzschwert" (short sword), and has very similar characteristics to the swords found in Orjahovo and V˘arbica II in Bulgaria. ### Formula representation The element concentration ratios involved in the paper are as follows: \[ \text{Sn/Cu}=\frac{\text{Sn concentration}}{\text{Cu concentration}} \] \[ \text{As/Sn}=\frac{\text{As concentration}}{\text{Sn concentration}} \] These ratios are used to avoid errors in absolute concentration calculations and help interpret the composition data. Figure 2 shows the concentration ratio diagram of Sn/Cu to As/Sn, which is used to visually show the composition relationships between different samples. Through these analyses, the researchers can draw conclusions about the composition of the Giurgiu sword and its relationship with swords in other regions.