Electronic-vibrational coupling in single-molecule devices

Vivek Aji,J.E. Moore,C.M. Varma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0302222

2003-03-11

Abstract:Experiments studying vibrational effects on electronic transport through single molecules have observed several seemingly inconsistent behaviors, ranging from up to 30 harmonics of a vibrational frequency in one experiment, to an absence of higher-harmonic peaks in another. We study the different manifestations of electronic-vibrational coupling in inelastic and elastic electron transport through single molecules. For the case of inelastic transport, higher harmonics are shown to be damped by additional small factors beyond powers of the electron-vibration coupling constant $\lambda$. Two mechanisms greatly increase the size of secondary peaks in inelastic transport: coupling between electron transport and spatial motion of the molecule, and the ``pumping'' of higher vibrational modes of the molecule when vibrational excitations do not completely relax between electron transits.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: In single - molecule devices, why does the influence of electron - vibration coupling on electron transport show significant differences in different experiments? Specifically, some experiments have observed vibration frequencies of up to 30 harmonics, while other experiments have hardly observed high - order harmonic peaks. By studying different mechanisms in elastic and inelastic electron transport, the author explains these seemingly contradictory phenomena.

### Main problems and background

1. **Inconsistency of experimental phenomena**
- In some experiments, vibration frequencies of up to 30 harmonics have been observed.
- In other experiments, high - order harmonic peaks are hardly visible.

2. **Research objectives**
- Explain why the performance of electron - vibration coupling is so different in different experiments.
- Study the specific mechanisms of electron - vibration coupling in elastic and inelastic transport.

### Research methods

The author uses a simplified Einstein - type model, assuming that the system is at zero temperature and out of resonance. They consider the following key factors:

1. **High - order harmonic attenuation in inelastic transport**
- The author finds that as the number of vibration modes \(n\) increases, the height of the inelastic step drops rapidly. This is due to additional small factors (such as powers of the electron - vibration coupling constant \(\lambda\)).

2. **Two mechanisms for enhancing the second - order peak**
- Coupling between electron transport and molecular spatial motion.
- When vibrational excitation cannot be completely relaxed between electron passages, "pumping" high - order vibration modes of the molecule.

3. **Effects in elastic transport**
- In elastic transport, electron - vibration coupling mainly affects the shape and weight of the resonance tunneling peak. For small \(\lambda\), the weight of the elastic sub - peak decays exponentially with \(n\), but there is no additional factor such as \(\bar{h}\omega / \tilde{\epsilon}_d\).

4. **"Pumping" mechanism**
- When the current is high enough, transporting electrons will continuously excite and relax the vibration modes of the molecule, thus significantly enhancing the vibration effect.

5. **Influence of molecular spatial motion**
- The oscillation of the center of mass of the molecule will affect its wave function overlap with the electrodes, thereby changing the tunneling rates \(\Gamma_L\) and \(\Gamma_R\). This can explain the enhancement of high - order harmonic peaks observed in the experiment.

### Conclusions

Through the above analysis, the author explains why high - order harmonic peaks can be seen in some experiments while not in others. The main conclusions include:

- **Orthogonality constraint in inelastic transport**: Causes rapid attenuation of high - order harmonic peaks.
- **"Pumping" mechanism**: Significantly enhances the vibration effect at high currents.
- **Influence of molecular spatial motion**: Enhances the intensity of the elastic tunneling peak.

These results not only explain the inconsistency in the experiments but also provide a theoretical basis for understanding electron - vibration coupling in single - molecule devices.

### Related formulas

1. **Einstein Hamiltonian**
\[
H_d=\hbar\omega b^\dagger b+\epsilon_d c^\dagger c+\lambda\hbar\omega c^\dagger c(b + b^\dagger)
\]

2. **Matrix elements**
\[
\langle 0,n|c|1,k\rangle = e^{-\lambda^2/2}\sum_{l + m=n}\frac{\lambda^{k + n-2l}(-1)^{n - l}}{\sqrt{k!n!(n - l)!(k - l)!l!}}
\]

3. **Step size in differential conductance**
\[
K_n=\frac{\hbar}{2e^2}\left(\left.\frac{dI}{dV}\right|_