Chronology Protection in String Theory

Lisa Dyson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2004/03/024
2003-08-16
Abstract:Many solutions of General Relativity appear to allow the possibility of time travel. This was initially a fascinating discovery, but geometries of this type violate causality, a basic physical law which is believed to be fundamental. Although string theory is a proposed fundamental theory of quantum gravity, geometries with closed timelike curves have resurfaced as solutions to its low energy equations of motion. In this paper, we will study the class of solutions to low energy effective supergravity theories related to the BMPV black hole and the rotating Wave--D1--D5--brane system. Time travel appears to be possible in these geometries. We will attempt to build the causality violating regions and propose that stringy effects prohibit their construction. We will show how the geometry is corrected and that, once corrected, causality is preserved. We will track our chronology protection proposal in the dual conformal field theory. The absence of closed timelike curves in the geometry coincides with the preservation of unitarity in the conformal field theory. The agent of chronology protection for the geometries studied here mirrors the enhancon mechanism, a mechanism string theory employs to resolve a class of naked singularities.
High Energy Physics - Theory,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to protect causality in the framework of string theory and prevent the emergence of closed timelike curves (CTCs)**. ### Problem Background There are some solutions in general relativity that allow the possibility of time travel. These solutions include Gödel's universe, Kerr black holes, and Gott's time machine, etc. However, these geometric structures violate causality, a fundamental physical law, which leads to many physical inconsistencies, such as the Grandmother paradox and the Bootstrap paradox. Therefore, scientists have been looking for a mechanism to prevent the formation of these causality - violating regions. ### Causality Protection in String Theory String theory, as a theory of quantum gravity, is considered to be able to provide a solution. Specifically, the author studied the solutions related to BMPV black holes and rotating Wave - D1 - D5 - brane systems in the low - energy effective supergravity theory. These geometric structures allow time travel under certain conditions, but the author proposes that string effects may prohibit the construction of these causality - violating regions. ### Main Research Contents 1. **Geometric Analysis**: - The author first explored in detail the geometric structure of five - dimensional rotating black holes and generalized it to ten - dimensional D - brane geometry. - In the five - dimensional geometry, when the angular momentum parameter \( J \) exceeds a certain critical value, closed timelike curves will appear outside the event horizon, leading to serious causality violations. - By lifting to ten dimensions, the author found that these causality - pathological regions still exist in higher dimensions. 2. **Dual Field Theory Analysis**: - The author studied the conformal field theory (CFT) in AdS/CFT duality and found that causality constraints are consistent with unitarity constraints in CFT. - Specifically, when \( J^2>4Q_1Q_5Q_k \), the closed timelike curves in the geometric structure will lead to non - unitarity in CFT. 3. **Causality Protection Mechanism**: - The author proposed a causality protection mechanism, similar to the enhanceton mechanism in string theory, to solve the problem of naked singularities. - When attempting to introduce rotating gravitational waves into the geometric structure, negative energy density will appear before reaching the causality - pathological region, thus preventing these gravitational waves from further entering. - The results show that there is a "causality protection radius" \( R_{cp} \), outside of which gravitational waves will spread on the shell instead of continuing to move inward, thus avoiding the formation of causality - violating regions. ### Conclusion The author proposes that there indeed exists a causality protection mechanism in string theory to prevent the emergence of closed timelike curves. Specifically, when the angular momentum parameter exceeds a certain limit, new mass - less degrees of freedom will appear at specific locations, preventing gravitational waves from entering the causality - pathological regions. Therefore, the finally corrected geometric structure is causally safe and meets the requirements of physical consistency. Through this mechanism, string theory not only solves some causality paradoxes in general relativity but also ensures the unitarity in conformal field theory, thus protecting the causal structure of spacetime.