Proposal for a New Test of the Time Independence Of The Fine Structure Constant, alpha, Using Orthogonally Polarised Whispering Gallery Modes in a Single Sapphire Resonator

Michael Edmund Tobar,John Gideon Hartnett
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.67.062001
2003-01-28
Abstract:A new experiment to test for the time independence of the fine structure constant, alpha, is proposed. The experiment utilizes orthogonally polarized Transverse Electric and Transverse Magnetic Whispering Gallery Modes in a single sapphire resonator tuned to similar frequencies. When configured as a dual mode sapphire clock, we show that the anisotropy of sapphire makes it is possible to undertake a sensitive measurement from the beat frequency between the two modes. At infrared frequencies this is possible due to the different effect of the lowest phonon frequency on the two orthogonally polarized modes. At microwave frequencies we show that the phonon effect is too small. We show that the Electron Spin Resonance of paramagnetic impurities (such as Cr3+) in the lattice effects only one polarization with an alpha^6 dependence. This enables an enhancement of the sensitivity to temporal changes in a at microwave frequencies.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to test the time - independence of the fine - structure constant (α). Specifically, the author proposes a new method to detect whether the fine - structure constant α changes over time by using the whispering - gallery modes (WGMs) of orthogonal polarizations in a single sapphire resonator. ### Detailed Explanation 1. **Background Problem** - The fine - structure constant α is a fundamental physical constant and plays an important role in electromagnetic interactions. - One of the major tasks in physics is to quantify gravity and unify all interactions, which may lead to deviations from existing physical theories, such as violations of Einstein's equivalence principle. - These deviations may manifest as spatial or temporal changes in fundamental physical constants (such as α). Therefore, measuring these changes is crucial for validating new physical theories. 2. **Limitations of Existing Methods** - Traditional methods usually rely on comparing two clocks with different α - dependencies or analyzing astrophysical and geophysical data. - These methods have low sensitivity in certain frequency ranges (such as the microwave band). 3. **Advantages of the New Method** - The author proposes to utilize the anisotropic properties of sapphire material, by exciting two orthogonal polarization modes (TE and TM modes) in the same resonator and measuring the beat frequency between these two modes. - The anisotropy of sapphire enables the two modes to sample different dispersion characteristics even at nearly the same frequency, thus increasing the sensitivity to α - changes. - At infrared frequencies, the lowest phonon frequency has different effects on the two orthogonal polarization modes, while at microwave frequencies, this effect is smaller. Therefore, the author introduces Cr³⁺ ions and uses their electron - spin - resonance (ESR) effect to significantly enhance the sensitivity to α - changes. 4. **Experimental Design** - The experimental setup includes a dual - mode sapphire resonator cooled to 4 K. - By precisely measuring the beat frequency between the TE and TM modes, minute changes in α can be detected. - If changes in α are detected, multiple systems need to be constructed to rule out the influence of system drift. 5. **Theoretical Basis** - The paper derives the relationship between the dielectric constant of sapphire material and the fine - structure constant α, and calculates the sensitivity functions at different frequencies. - By introducing Cr³⁺ ions, the sensitivity at microwave frequencies is further increased because the ESR frequency of Cr³⁺ is proportional to the sixth power of α. ### Summary This paper aims to test the time - independence of the fine - structure constant α with high precision through an innovative experimental method using the whispering - gallery modes of orthogonal polarizations in a sapphire resonator. This method not only improves the sensitivity to α - changes but also provides new tools and ideas for future fundamental physics research.