Acute rehabilitation after traumatic shoulder dislocation

Margie Olds,Gisela Sole

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q21

2024-01-18

BMJ

Abstract:Most anterior shoulder dislocations occur for the first time related to sports (59%1 to 74%2), or from falls.1 Following closed reduction, primary care for these injuries involves a supportive sling and individually tailored advice for optimising recovery such as rehabilitative exercises to improve range of motion, sensorimotor control, strength, and function. To inform decision making, a linked BMJ paper by Kearney and colleagues (doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-076925) compared the effectiveness of two different approaches to acute rehabilitation following anterior shoulder dislocations (ARTISAN) across 40 hospital sites in the UK's National Health Service. The approaches were advice, supporting materials, and the option to self-refer to physiotherapy, or the same advice and supporting materials alongside a tailored programme of physiotherapy.3This randomised clinical trial was well planned, executed, and reported, and the authors should be commended for conducting a trial involving 482 patients (at baseline) and 96 clinicians during the covid-19 pandemic.The primary outcome measure, the...

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is whether physical therapy is necessary during the rehabilitation process following an acute traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation. Specifically, the researchers compared the effectiveness of two different rehabilitation methods through a randomized clinical trial (ARTISAN): one that provided only counseling and support materials, and another that added a personalized physical therapy plan to the counseling and support materials. The main objective of the study was to assess the impact of these two methods on the recovery of shoulder function in patients and to explore whether all patients need physical therapy.

The study results indicated that adding a personalized physical therapy plan was not significantly more effective than providing only counseling and support materials. This suggests that in some cases, patients might opt to first receive counseling and support materials and seek physical therapy if needed. However, the study also pointed out some limitations and directions for future research, such as differences among patients of different age groups, psychological factors like fear of re-injury, and specific sports and occupational demands.