Implementation challenges for a constructivist physical education curriculum

Xihe Zhu,Catherine D. Ennis,Ang Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17408981003712802
2011-01-01
Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy
Abstract:BACKGROUND: Curriculum fidelity describes the extent to which a curriculum is implemented faithfully as planned. Curriculum fidelity issues may arise when teachers implement the curriculum inconsistently due to differences in philosophy, barriers in the setting, or other local concerns.PURPOSE: The study examined challenges that a teacher faced in implementing a constructivist physical education curriculum that had fidelity implications.RESEARCH DESIGN: Ethnographic case study design was employed in the research.PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: One physical education teacher, Daniel, and his students in third, fourth, and fifth grade participated in the study as they were involved in a curriculum intervention in a large urban school district in the U.S. Daniel's school was assigned randomly to experiment group to implement a physical education curriculum based on health/fitness related science.DATA COLLECTION: The researchers observed 75 lessons taught by Daniel using non-participant observation techniques and conducted two structured interviews with Daniel and eight interviews with his students.DATA ANALYSIS: Constant comparison with open and axial coding was used to analyze the observation and interview data.FINDINGS: Two thematic challenges emerged: (a) school contextual constraints that limited the fitness science learning environment in physical education, and (b) Daniel's personal value and preference for a recreational rather than a science-based physical education program. These challenges impacted Daniel's decisions when teaching the curriculum.
education & educational research
What problem does this paper attempt to address?