Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy under different anesthetic methods
Wang Jun,Cai Haihe,Li Shuiqing
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2007.03.040
2007-01-01
Abstract:Objective To observe changes of vital signs during percutaneous dilational tracheostomy(PDT) under different anesthetic methods.Methods Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy was performed in 60 patients undergoing cervical spine surgery.They were randomly divided into three groups with 20 patients in each group,receiving local anesthesia(Group Ⅰ),endotracheal intubation(Group Ⅱ),or intubating laryngeal mask airway(Group Ⅲ),respectively.The heart rate(HR),mean arterial pressure(MAP),oxygen saturation by pulse oximetry(SPO2),time for tracheostomy,and postoperative complications were recorded at the time before operation(T1),during tracheostomy(T2),1 min(T3),3 min(T4),and 5 min(T5) after tracheostomy,respectively.Results The time for tracheostomy was 7.6±1.8 min in the Group I,4.8±0.7 min in the Group II,and 5.0±0.8 min in the Group Ⅲ,respectively.At the time points of T2,T3,and T4,the MAP in the Group I was 96.3±11.2 mm Hg,98.5±10.5 mm Hg,and 95.6±13.1 mm Hg,respectively,which was significantly higher than that in the Group Ⅱ(87.6±7.3 mm Hg,q=3.979,P<0.05;88.4±6.5 mm Hg,q=4.962,P<0.05;86.4±7.9 mmHg,q=3.817,P<0.05) and Group Ⅲ(T3: 91.6±9.8 mm Hg,q=3.390,P<0.05).There was no significant difference in MAP between the Group II and the Group Ⅲ at all time points(P>0.05).At the time points of T2,T3,T4,and T5,the HR in the Group I was 92±7,90±6,92±7,and 81±5,respectively,which was significantly higher than that in the Group Ⅱ(76±3,q=14.407,P<0.05;75±5,q=11.797,P<0.05;76±5,q=13.234,P<0.05;75±6,q=5.505,P<0.05) and the Group Ⅲ(77±4,q=13.507,P<0.05;76±6,q=11.011,P<0.05;75±5,q=12.456,P<0.05;74±6,q=4.719,P<0.05).There was no significant difference in HR between the Group Ⅱ and the Group Ⅲ at all time points (P>0.05).At the T2,the SaPO2 in the Group I(97%±3%) was significantly lower than that in the Group Ⅲ(99%±1%)(q=4.140,P<0.05),but had no statistical difference with that in the Group Ⅱ(98%±2%;q=2.070,P>0.05).At the other time points,no significant difference was observed in SPO2 among the three groups(P>0.05).Various degrees of pharyngalgia and hoarseness occurred in 2 patients in the Group Ⅰ,3 patients in the Group Ⅱ,and 2 in the Group Ⅲ,the incidence of complications being not statistically different(χ2=0.323,P=0.851).Conclusions Compared with local anesthesia or endotracheal intubation,percutaneous dilational tracheostomy under laryngeal mask airway ventilation offers more stable circulation,higher reliability,and less influence to tracheostomy.This technique may give certain protection against cervical spinal cord injury during anesthetic induction.