Abstract:In recent work by M.H.Lynch, E.Cohen, Y.Hadad and I.Kaminer (LCHK), a modified model of the Unruh-DeWitt quantum detector, coupled to a 4-vector current, has been proposed to examine the radiation emitted by high energy positrons channeled into silicon crystal samples. Inspired by their ideas, we analyze theoretical aspects of such a model, its internal consistency, and ignore all questions related to experiments. The two-potential correlation functions for the quantized electromagnetic field in a vacuum state and the corresponding detector radiation power (DRP), considered in proper time formalism, are used as the basis for investigating the radiation observed at an accelerating point detector. The quantum detector is assumed to be moving through an electromagnetic vacuum along a classical hyperbolic trajectory with a constant proper acceleration. The DRP is obtained for three possible cases. First, the DRP is found in a Lorentz-invariant manner. It contains both transverse and non-physical longitudinal polarization modes and is a divergent quantity. Second, the radiation power holds only physical transverse modes but it is non-relativistic and also depends on the detector proper time, which contradicts the fact that there is no preferred time for hyperbolic detector motion. Third, in the case considered by LCHK, for zero detector proper time when its velocity in the lab inertial system is zero, the radiation power with transverse modes shows some signs of thermality which could be associated with a detector acceleration but different from the Bose-Einstein statistics expected for the photon field. If the detector energy gap is zero then, in complete contradiction with what LCHK claim, there is no radiation and no "thermalized Larmor formula". Based on our analysis we do not believe that the LCHK's model can be used to support the idea about thermal effects of uniform acceleration.

Measuring Unruh radiation from accelerated electrons

Measuring Unruh radiation from accelerated electrons

A new study of the Unruh effect

Unruh radiation produced by a uniformly accelerating charged particle in thermal random motions

Unruh Effect of Detectors with Quantized Center-of-Mass

Macroscopic aspects of the Unruh effect

Strong Noninertial Radiative Shifts in Atomic Spectra at Low Accelerations

Some Theoretical Aspects of Observation of Acceleration Induced Thermality

On the Measurement of the Unruh Effect Through Extended Quantum Thermometers

Limits to the observation of the Unruh radiation via first-quantized hydrogen-like atoms

Quantum radiation produced by a uniformly accelerating charged particle in thermal random motion

Quantum simulation of Unruh radiation

Unruh radiation and Interference effect

Accelerated electron thermometer: observation of 1D Planck radiation

Everything is a "matter" of perspective: the Unruh effect

Classical Larmor formula through the Unruh effect for uniformly accelerated electrons

Acceleration and radiation: Classical and quantum aspects

Measuring Electron Energy in Muon-to-Electron Conversion using Holographic Synchrotron Radiation Emission Spectroscopy

Coherent Unipolar Cherenkov and Diffraction Radiation Generated by Relativistic Electrons

Thermality of the Unruh effect with intermediate statistics