Abstract:SIAM Journal on Computing, Volume 53, Issue 1, Page 1-46, February 2024. We consider the problem of finding nearly optimal solutions of optimization problems with random objective functions. Such problems arise widely in the theory of random graphs, theoretical computer science, and statistical physics. Two concrete problems we consider are (a) optimizing the Hamiltonian of a spherical or Ising [math]-spin glass model and (b) finding a large independent set in a sparse Erdős–Rényi graph. The following families of algorithms are considered: (a) low-degree polynomials of the input—a general framework that captures many prior algorithms; (b) low-depth Boolean circuits; (c) the Langevin dynamics algorithm, a canonical Monte Carlo analogue of the gradient descent algorithm. We show that these families of algorithms cannot have high success probability. For the case of Boolean circuits, our results improve the state-of-the-art bounds known in circuit complexity theory (although we consider the search problem as opposed to the decision problem). Our proof uses the fact that these models are known to exhibit a variant of the overlap gap property (OGP) of near-optimal solutions. Specifically, for both models, every two solutions whose objectives are above a certain threshold are either close to or far from each other. The crux of our proof is that the classes of algorithms we consider exhibit a form of stability (noise-insensitivity): a small perturbation of the input induces a small perturbation of the output. We show by an interpolation argument that stable algorithms cannot overcome the OGP barrier. The stability of Langevin dynamics is an immediate consequence of the well-posedness of stochastic differential equations. The stability of low-degree polynomials and Boolean circuits is established using tools from Gaussian and Boolean analysis—namely hypercontractivity and total influence, as well as a novel lower bound for random walks avoiding certain subsets, which we expect to be of independent interest. In the case of Boolean circuits, the result also makes use of Linial–Mansour–Nisan's classical theorem. Our techniques apply more broadly to low influence functions, and we expect that they may apply more generally.

Optimization and Physics: On the satisfiability of random Boolean formulae

Hardness of Random Optimization Problems for Boolean Circuits, Low-Degree Polynomials, and Langevin Dynamics

On modeling hard combinatorial optimization problems as linear programs: Refutations of the "unconditional impossibility" claims

General Bounds on Satisfiability Thresholds for Random CSPs via Fourier Analysis

The Connectivity of Boolean Satisfiability: Dichotomies for Formulas and Circuits

Estimating the Volume of Solution Space for Satisfiability Modulo Linear Real Arithmetic

Resource-distribution via Boolean constraints

On the random satisfiable process

Logical Primes, Metavariables and Satisfiability

Minimizing Expected Cost Under Hard Boolean Constraints, with Applications to Quantitative Synthesis

The Lovász Local Lemma and Satisfiability

Optimization of random cost functions and statistical physics

Bose-Einstein Condensation in Satisfiability Problems

On Theoretical Complexity and Boolean Satisfiability

Algebraic characteristics and satisfiability threshold of random Boolean equations.

Minimization for Generalized Boolean Formulas

Solving Set Optimization Problems by Cardinality Optimization via Weak Constraints with an Application to Argumentation

On the Complexity of Combinatorial Optimization on Fixed Structures

Physics Successfully Implements Lagrange Multiplier Optimization

Unifying Framework for Optimizations in Non-Boolean Formalisms

From one solution of a 3-satisfiability formula to a solution cluster: Frozen variables and entropy