Dispersion Relations and Inconsistency of $ρ$ data

O.V. Selyugin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/0212308

2002-12-20

Abstract:The high energy elastic nucleon cross section is treated from the viewpoint of the basic principles of local field theory. The connection between the energy dependence of $\sigma_{tot}$ and the $\rho$ - ratio of the real to imaginary parts of the forward elastic scattering amplitude is examined in the framework of dispersion relations, derivative dispersion relations and crossing symmetry.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the energy - dependence of the total cross - section \( \sigma_{\text{tot}} \) and the parameter \( \rho(s) \) (i.e., the ratio of the real part to the imaginary part of the forward elastic scattering amplitude) in the high - energy elastic nucleon scattering process. Specifically, starting from the basic principles of local field theory, the author explores the relationships between these quantities and uses dispersion relations, derivative dispersion relations and cross - symmetry to study their behaviors.

### Main problems

1. **Energy - dependence of total cross - section \( \sigma_{\text{tot}} \) and \( \rho(s) \)**
- The energy - dependence of the total cross - section \( \sigma_{\text{tot}} \) and \( \rho(s) \) in the high - energy region is a long - discussed but still undetermined problem.
- The author attempts to understand the behaviors of these quantities at different energies through dispersion relations and other theoretical tools.

2. **Validity and consistency of dispersion relations**
- Dispersion relations are derived based on properties such as causality, the optical theorem and polynomial boundedness, which relate the total cross - section \( \sigma_{\text{tot}} \) to the real part of the scattering amplitude.
- The paper examines whether the experimental data conform to these dispersion relations and explores the differences between different methods (such as integral dispersion relations and derivative dispersion relations).

3. **Consistency of experimental data**
- The author points out that although some experimental data seem to support the dispersion relations, when considering all experimental data, there are large \( \chi^2 \) values, indicating that there are contradictions among certain experimental data.
- These contradictions may stem from the treatment methods in the low - energy region and non - physical regions, as well as the choice of subtraction constants.

### Formula summary

- **Optical theorem**: The relationship connecting the total cross - section and the imaginary part of the scattering amplitude is
\[
\sigma_{\text{tot}}(s)=\frac{4\pi}{k}\Im F(s, t = 0)
\]
where \( k \) is the momentum in the center - of - mass system.

- **Integral dispersion relations**: Used to calculate the real part of the scattering amplitude
\[
\Re f_{\text{even}}(E)=\Re f_{\text{even}}(0)+\frac{P}{\pi}\int_{m}^{\infty}dE'\frac{E'^{2}E^{2}}{E'^{2}-E^{2}}\Im f_{\text{even}}(E')
\]
\[
\Re f_{\text{odd}}(E)=\frac{P}{\pi}\int_{m}^{\infty}dE'\frac{E E'}{E'^{2}-E^{2}}\Im f_{\text{odd}}(E')
\]

- **Derivative dispersion relations**: Applicable to the high - energy region
\[
\frac{\rho(s)}{s^{\alpha}}=\tan\left[\frac{\pi}{2}\left(\alpha - 1+\frac{d}{d\ln s}\right)\right]\frac{I(s)}{s^{\alpha}}
\]

### Conclusion

The author believes that although dispersion relations provide important theoretical guidance, due to the complexity of experimental data and the uncertainty in the treatment of the low - energy region, it is currently impossible to fully verify their validity. Especially in the low - energy region, the choice of subtraction constants has a great impact on the results, making the consistency between theoretical predictions and experimental data complicated. Therefore, further research and more accurate experimental data are crucial for verifying these theories.