C.R. Simovski,P.A. Belov,S. He
Abstract:A structure formed by combined lattices of infinitely long wires and split-ring resonators is studied. A dispersion equation is derived and then used to calculate the effective permittivity and permeability in the frequency band where the lattice can be homogenized. The backward wave region in which both the effective permittivity and permeability are negative is analyzed. Some open and controversial questions are discussed. It is shown that previous experimental results confirming the existence of backward waves in such a structure can be in deed explained in terms of negative material parameters. However, these parameters are not quasi-static and thus the known analytical formulas for the effective material parameters of this structure, which have been widely used and discussed in the literature, were not correct, and it was the reason of some objections to the authors of that experiment.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the negative material parameters (i.e., negative permittivity \(\epsilon\) and negative permeability \(\mu\)) exhibited by the structure composed of infinitely long wires and split - ring resonators (SRR) within a specific frequency range and their corresponding backward - wave regions. Specifically, the main research problems include:
1. **Whether this structure can be described with negative permittivity and permeability**: Previous experimental results have shown that this structure does indeed have a backward - wave phenomenon, but these material parameters are not quasi - static, so the previously widely used analytical formulas are not correct. This raises a question: how to accurately describe the effective material parameters of this structure?
2. **The influence of electromagnetic interaction**: The electromagnetic interaction between the wires and SRR is not quasi - static but non - local, which will significantly affect the calculation of the effective permittivity and permeability. Therefore, these interactions need to be considered to derive more accurate material parameters.
3. **The applicability of the homogenization model**: At certain frequencies within the SRR resonance band, the homogenization model may give an overly high effective permeability, causing the effective wavelength to become very small, thus invalidating the homogenization assumption. Therefore, it is necessary to clarify which frequency ranges can use the homogenization model and which cannot.
4. **The negative material parameter regions within the frequency band**: In particular, within the SRR resonance band, whether there are regions with both negative permittivity and negative permeability, and whether these parameters can explain the backward - wave phenomenon observed in experiments.
To answer these questions, the author developed a new analytical model, taking into account the non - local electromagnetic interaction between the wires and SRR, and calculated the effective permittivity and permeability through self - consistent dispersion equations. The research shows that the homogenization assumption is valid only within part of the frequency range of the SRR resonance band, and within this region, there are indeed negative material parameters and backward - wave phenomena.
### Key Formulas
- Expressions for effective permittivity and permeability:
\[
\epsilon = 1 - \frac{\omega_p^2}{\omega^2}
\]
\[
\epsilon = 1 - \frac{\omega_p^2 - \omega_e^2}{\omega^2 - \omega_e^2 - j\gamma\omega}
\]
\[
\mu = 1 - \frac{\omega_{mp}^2 - \omega_m^2}{\omega^2 - \omega_m^2 - j\gamma\omega}
\]
- Expression for magnetic polarizability:
\[
a_{mm} = \frac{2\mu_0^2 S^2 (\omega_0^2 / \omega^2 - 1)}{(L + L_{mut})(\omega_0^2 / \omega^2 - 1) - jR_r / \omega}
\]
- Dispersion equation:
\[
[2ab / (\omega\eta) \text{Re}(1/a_{mm}) - q] (\cos(kd) - \cos(\beta d)) \sin(kd) - (1 + kb / \pi \log(b / 2\pi r_0)) \sin^2(kd) - \cos^2(\beta d) + 1 = 0
\]
Through these formulas, the author can more accurately describe the electromagnetic characteristics of this complex structure and resolve some disputes and uncertainties in previous research.