Hydration and mobility of HO-(aq)

D. Asthagiri,Lawrence R. Pratt,J. D. Kress,Maria A. Gomez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0211057

2003-07-18

Abstract:The hydroxide anion plays an essential role in many chemical and biochemical reactions. But a molecular-scale description of its hydration state, and hence also its transport, in water is currently controversial. The statistical mechanical quasi-chemical theory of solutions suggests that HO[H2O]3- is the predominant species in the aqueous phase under standard conditions. This result is in close agreement with recent spectroscopic studies on hydroxide water clusters, and with the available thermodynamic hydration free energies. In contrast, a recent ab initio molecular dynamics simulation has suggested that HO[H_2O]4- is the only dominant aqueous solution species. We apply adiabatic ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, and find good agreement with both the quasi-chemical theoretical predictions and experimental results. The present results suggest a picture that is simpler, more traditional, but with additional subtlety. These coordination structures are labile but the tri-coordinate species is the prominent case. This conclusion is unaltered with changes in the electronic density functional. No evidence is found for rate-determining activated inter-conversion of a HO[H2O]4- trap structure to HO[H2O]3-, mediating hydroxide transport. The view of HO- diffusion as the hopping of a proton hole has substantial validity, the rate depending largely on the dynamic disorder of the water hydrogen-bond network.

Chemical Physics,Biological Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the hydration state of the hydrated hydroxide ion ($\text{HO}^-$) in water and its migration mechanism. Specifically, the research aims to clarify the following aspects:

1. **Hydration state**: Determine the main hydration structure of $\text{HO}^-$ in water. Currently, there is a controversy regarding this issue. Some studies believe that the main hydration structure is $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$, while others believe it is $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_4^-$.

2. **Migration mechanism**: Explore the migration process of $\text{HO}^-$ in water. In particular, whether effective migration needs to be achieved through the conversion from $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_4^-$ to $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$, and whether there is an energy barrier for this conversion.

### Research background

- **Theoretical research**: Statistical mechanics quasi - chemical theory predicts that $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$ is the main hydration structure.
- **Experimental research**: Spectroscopic studies and thermodynamic data support $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$ as the main structure.
- **Molecular dynamics simulation**: Early ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations found that $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_4^-$ is the main structure, but recent research results are at odds with these early simulations.

### Research methods

- **AIMD simulation**: Use the VASP software to conduct AIMD simulations to study the hydration structure and dynamic behavior of $\text{HO}^-$ in water.
- **Different density functionals**: Use different electron density functionals (such as PW91 and rPBE) for simulations to evaluate the impact of method selection on the results.

### Main conclusions

- **Main hydration structure**: The research results show that $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$ is the main hydration structure, although there is also a certain degree of $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_4^-$ structure.
- **Migration mechanism**: The migration of $\text{HO}^-$ is mainly achieved through the proton - hopping mechanism, rather than through the conversion from $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_4^-$ to $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$. The proton - hopping process depends on the dynamic disorder of the water - molecule hydrogen - bond network.

### Significance

- **Consistency between theory and experiment**: The research results are consistent with theoretical and experimental data, further confirming that $\text{HO} \cdot [\text{H}_2\text{O}]_3^-$ is the main hydration structure.
- **Clarification of migration mechanism**: The migration mechanism of $\text{HO}^-$ is clarified, which is helpful for understanding the ion - transport behavior in aqueous solutions and is of great significance for chemical and biochemical reactions.

In summary, through AIMD simulations and in combination with theoretical and experimental data, this paper resolves the controversy regarding the hydration state and migration mechanism of $\text{HO}^-$, providing an important reference for research in related fields.