Sudhansu S. Mandal,Jainendra K. Jain
Abstract:Almost all quantum Hall effect to date can be understood as {\em integral} quantum Hall effect of appropriate particles, namely electrons or composite fermions. This paper investigates theoretically the feasibility of nested states of composite fermions which would lead to a quantum Hall effect that cannot be understood as integral quantum Hall effect of composite fermions. The weak residual interaction between composite fermions will play a crucial role in the establishment of such quantum Hall states by opening a gap in a partially filled composite-fermion level. To treat the problem of interacting composite fermions, we develop a powerful method that allows us to obtain the low energy spectra at composite fermion fillings of $\nu^*=n+\bar \nu$ without making any assumption regarding the structure of composite fermions in the topmost partially filled level. The method is exact aside from neglecting the composite-fermion Landau level mixing, and enables us to study rather large systems, for example, 24 particles at a total flux of 62 $hc/e$, for which the dimension of the lowest Landau level Hilbert space is $\sim 10^{17}$. We have investigated, for fully spin polarized composite fermions, several filling factors between 1/3 and 2/5 using this approach. The results indicate that any possible incompressibility at these fractions is likely to have a fundamentally different origin than that considered earlier.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the possibility of composite fermions forming the nested quantum Hall effect (NQHE) in partially filled energy levels. Specifically, the authors studied whether quantum Hall states that cannot be simply understood as the integer quantum Hall effect can be generated when the weak residual interactions between composite fermions open the energy gaps in partially filled energy levels.
### Research Background
1. **Integer Quantum Hall Effect (IQHE) and Fractional Quantum Hall Effect (FQHE)**
- If there are no interactions between electrons, only the integer quantum Hall effect will occur.
- The discovery of the fractional quantum Hall effect indicates the existence of a new correlated matter state, namely composite fermions composed of electrons and quantized vortices.
2. **Characteristics of Composite Fermions**
- The effective magnetic induction intensity \( B^* \) of composite fermions is given by the following formula:
\[
B^* = B - 2p\rho\phi_0
\]
where \( B \) is the external magnetic field, \( \rho \) is the two - dimensional electron density, \( 2p \) is the vorticity of composite fermions, and \( \phi_0=\frac{hc}{e} \) is the magnetic flux quantum.
3. **Known Fractional Filling Factors**
- Many known quantum Hall effects can be explained by the non - interacting composite fermion model, for example:
\[
\nu=\frac{n}{2pn\pm1}
\]
### Research Problem
The authors are concerned with whether there are new quantum Hall states in the partially filled energy levels between two consecutive integer filling factors. These new states are called nested quantum Hall effects (NQHE), which cannot be simply explained by the integer quantum Hall effect.
### Main Research Contents
1. **Theoretical Framework**
- A powerful method has been developed to obtain the low - energy spectrum without assuming the composite fermion structure.
- The method allows the study of larger systems, such as 24 particles in the case where the total magnetic flux is 62\(\frac{hc}{e}\).
2. **Numerical Simulation**
- The matrix elements are calculated using the Monte Carlo method, and an orthogonal basis is constructed through the Gram - Schmidt orthogonalization process.
- A detailed study has been carried out for specific filling factors (such as \(\nu = \frac{4}{11}, \frac{5}{13}, \frac{7}{19}, \frac{6}{17}\)).
3. **Results and Discussion**
- The results show that under these filling factors, there may indeed be new incompressible states.
- The physical mechanisms of these new states are different from the traditional integer quantum Hall effect, but are caused by the weak residual interactions between composite fermions.
### Significance
This research not only expands our understanding of the quantum Hall effect, but also provides a theoretical basis for the possible observation of more nested quantum Hall states in the future. In particular, it helps to explain the \(\nu=\frac{4}{11}\) and \(\nu = \frac{5}{13}\) states observed in recent experiments, which cannot be explained by traditional theories.
In conclusion, the main purpose of this paper is to explore the possibility of composite fermions forming new quantum Hall states in partially filled energy levels, and to verify the existence of these states and their physical mechanisms through theoretical and numerical simulations.