B.F. Bayman,F.Zardi
Abstract:The long-wavelength approximation and the truncated Taylor expansion are frequently used in the theory of relativistic Coulomb excitation to obtain multipole expansions of the interaction. It is shown in this note that these two approximations are exactly equivalent.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the equivalence of two commonly - used approximation methods in relativistic Coulomb excitation. Specifically, the author explores whether the long - wavelength approximation (LWLA) and the truncated Taylor expansion (TTEA) are equivalent when dealing with relativistic Coulomb excitation.
### Problem Background
Relativistic Coulomb excitation is an important tool for studying multiple aspects in nuclear structure that cannot be explored through nuclear interactions. In analyzing relativistic Coulomb excitation, an important quantity is the retarded scalar potential \( \Phi(\mathbf{r}, t) \), which describes the electric potential generated by a projectile moving along a straight - line trajectory at a velocity \( v \) at position \( \mathbf{r} \) and time \( t \):
\[
\Phi(\mathbf{r}, t)=\frac{ZPe}{\gamma \sqrt{(x - b_x)^2+(y - b_y)^2+\gamma^2(z - vt)^2}}
\]
where \( ZP e \) is the charge of the projectile, \( b \) is the impact parameter of the trajectory, and \( \phi_b \) is the angle between the reaction plane and the \( \hat{x}-\hat{z} \) plane.
To calculate the matrix elements of electromagnetic interactions and use them in coupled - channel time - dependent differential equations, a multipole expansion of \( \Phi(\mathbf{r}, t) \) is required. However, there is no exact multipole expansion form for \( \Phi(\mathbf{r}, t) \). Therefore, researchers have developed two approximation methods: LWLA and TTEA.
### Long - Wavelength Approximation (LWLA)
LWLA obtains the following approximation by truncating the spherical Bessel function and only retaining the first term:
\[
\Phi(\mathbf{r}, t)\sim\sum_{\lambda, \mu}A_{\lambda, \lambda}^\mu\frac{r^\lambda Y_\lambda^\mu(\hat{\mathbf{r}})}{r^\lambda}
\]
### Truncated Taylor Expansion (TTEA)
TTEA obtains the following approximation by performing a Taylor expansion of \( \Phi(\mathbf{r}, t) \) and truncating the terms up to \( \ell = \lambda \):
\[
\Phi(\mathbf{r}, t)\sim\sum_{\lambda, \mu}B_{\lambda, \lambda}^\mu\frac{r^\lambda Y_\lambda^\mu(\hat{\mathbf{r}})}{r^\lambda}
\]
### Equivalence Proof
Through detailed mathematical derivations, the author proves that these two approximation methods are completely equivalent when \( \ell = \lambda \). Specifically, both LWLA and TTEA perform the same truncation in the multipole expansion of \( \Phi(\mathbf{r}, t) \), that is, only retaining the terms with \( \ell = \lambda \). Therefore, the results of the two approximation methods have the same effective range.
### Conclusion
The main conclusion of this paper is that LWLA and TTEA are equivalent in the multipole expansion of relativistic Coulomb excitation. This result helps to simplify theoretical calculations and provides a solid theoretical basis for future experimental and theoretical research.