The Partition Ensemble Fallacy Fallacy

Kae Nemoto,Samuel L. Braunstein
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.quant-ph/0207135
2002-07-23
Abstract:The Partition Ensemble Fallacy was recently applied to claim no quantum coherence exists in coherent states produced by lasers. We show that this claim relies on an untestable belief of a particular prior distribution of absolute phase. One's choice for the prior distribution for an unobservable quantity is a matter of `religion'. We call this principle the Partition Ensemble Fallacy Fallacy. Further, we show an alternative approach to construct a relative-quantity Hilbert subspace where unobservability of certain quantities is guaranteed by global conservation laws. This approach is applied to coherent states and constructs an approximate relative-phase Hilbert subspace.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?