High proper motion white dwarfs and halo dark matter

Santiago Torres,Enrique Garcia-Berro,Andreas Burkert,Jordi Isern

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05830.x

2002-07-19

Abstract:The interpretation of the old, cool white dwarfs recently found by Oppenheimer et al. (2001) is still controversial. Whereas these authors claim that they have finally found the elusive ancient halo white dwarf population that contributes significantly to the mass budget of the galactic halo, there have been several other contributions that argue that these white dwarfs are not genuine halo members but, instead, thick disk stars. We show here that the interpretation of this sample is based on the adopted distances, which are obtained from a color--magnitude calibration, and we demonstrate that when the correct distances are used a sizeable fraction of these putative halo white dwarfs belong indeed to the disk population. We also perform a maximum likelihood analysis of the remaining set of white dwarfs and we find that they most likely belong to the thick disk population. However, another possible explanation is that this sample of white dwarfs has been drawn from a 1:1 mixture of the halo and disk white dwarf populations.

Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether high - velocity proper - motion white dwarfs are part of the dark matter in the Galactic halo. Specifically, Oppenheimer et al. (2001) discovered a group of cold white dwarfs with high - velocity proper - motion and claimed that these white dwarfs might belong to the ancient Galactic halo white dwarf population, thus making a significant contribution to the dark matter mass budget of the Galactic halo.

However, this conclusion is controversial. Some studies suggest that these white dwarfs may actually be members of the thick - disk stellar population rather than true halo white dwarfs. Therefore, the main problems of this paper can be summarized as follows:

1. **Confirm whether the white dwarfs discovered by Oppenheimer et al. do belong to the Galactic halo**: The author re - evaluated the distance calibration method used by Oppenheimer et al. and pointed out that these distances may be biased, leading to misjudgment of the white dwarf's stellar population.

2. **Evaluate the contribution of these white dwarfs to the Galactic halo dark matter**: By recalculating the distances and using maximum - likelihood analysis, the author attempts to determine which stellar population (halo or thick - disk) these white dwarfs are more likely to belong to and their potential contribution to the Galactic halo dark matter.

### Specific problem analysis

- **Distance calibration problem**:
- Oppenheimer et al. used color - magnitude calibration to estimate the distances of white dwarfs, but this calibration method may lead to inaccurate distance estimates. The author pointed out that for bright white dwarfs, the distances are underestimated, while for low - luminosity white dwarfs, the distances are overestimated.

- **Stellar population membership of the sample**:
- The author used Monte Carlo simulations and maximum - likelihood analysis to evaluate which stellar population these white dwarfs are more likely to belong to. The results show that the velocity distributions of a considerable number of white dwarfs are more consistent with the thick - disk stellar population rather than the halo stellar population.

- **Dark matter contribution**:
- If these white dwarfs mainly belong to the thick - disk rather than the halo, their contribution to the Galactic halo dark matter will be greatly reduced. The author also discussed other possible explanations, such as the possible mixture of halo and disk white dwarfs in the sample.

### Conclusion

By re - evaluating the distance calibration and stellar population membership, this paper concludes that a considerable number of the white dwarfs discovered by Oppenheimer et al. are more likely to be members of the thick - disk stellar population rather than halo white dwarfs. Therefore, the contribution of these white dwarfs to the Galactic halo dark matter may be much smaller than previously estimated.