Trade-offs Among Ecosystem Services After Vegetation Restoration in China’s Loess Plateau

Peng Shi,Zhanbin Li,Peng Li,Yan Zhang,Binbin Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11053-021-09841-5
IF: 5.609
2021-02-23
Natural Resources Research
Abstract:A large-scale vegetation restoration program that was implemented in China's Loess Plateau has significantly changed ecosystem patterns, resulting in variations in ecosystem services. However, trade-offs among multiple ecosystem services were rarely considered after land-use changes have occurred. To understand the impact of vegetation restoration on those ecosystem services, 139 soil samples were collected from forestland, shrubland, grassland, and sloping cropland across the Wangmaogou watershed to assess soil organic carbon storage (SOCS), soil water content (SWC), soil total nitrogen storage (STNS), and soil conservation service (SCS) changes. Values of SOCS in shrubland (6.91 kg m<sup>−2</sup>), grassland (7.18 kg m<sup>−2</sup>), and forestland (7.31 kg m<sup>−2</sup>) were higher than in sloping cropland (6.02 kg m<sup>−2</sup>). Likewise, SCS and STNS were higher in vegetation land-use than in sloping cropland. However, SWC decreased in grassland, shrubland, and forestland compared to sloping cropland. The trends in SWC and other ecosystem services showed high trade-offs. Grassland had higher effects for SWC–SOCS and SWC–STNS than did forest- or shrubland. To coordinate ecosystem services and maintain regional sustainable development, grassland was suggested as a more effective land-use type in the water limited areas. In addition, reasonable planting density should be considered in future vegetation restoration.
geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to study the impact of vegetation restoration on ecosystem services in the Loess Plateau region of China and to explore the trade-offs between different land use types. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Research Background**: The Loess Plateau is the largest loess deposit area in China and one of the most severely affected regions by soil erosion globally. Since 1999, the Chinese government has implemented the "Grain for Green Project" (GFGP) to reduce soil erosion. 2. **Research Objectives**: To evaluate the impact of vegetation restoration on ecosystem service indicators such as soil organic carbon storage (SOCS), soil water content (SWC), soil total nitrogen storage (STNS), and soil conservation service (SCS), and to analyze the trade-offs between these indicators. 3. **Main Findings**: - Vegetation restoration significantly increased soil organic carbon storage and soil total nitrogen storage but decreased soil water content. - Grasslands are more effective than forests or shrublands in semi-arid areas because they can maintain higher levels of other ecosystem services while providing higher soil water content. - Shrublands contribute less to ecosystem services due to their higher water demand. - Reasonable planting density is crucial for maintaining soil water content. 4. **Conclusion**: Grasslands are the most suitable land use type for vegetation restoration in the Loess Plateau region, especially in areas with limited water resources. Additionally, native plants should be prioritized, and reasonable planting density should be considered to achieve a win-win situation between soil water retention and other ecosystem services. Through this study, the authors provide important scientific evidence for future land use planning, which will help promote regional sustainable development.