Abstract:Modern automation systems largely rely on closed loop control, wherein a controller interacts with a controlled process via actions, based on observations. These systems are increasingly complex, yet most deployed controllers are linear Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers. PID controllers perform well on linear and near-linear systems but their simplicity is at odds with the robustness required to reliably control complex processes. Modern machine learning techniques offer a way to extend PID controllers beyond their linear control capabilities by using neural networks. However, such an extension comes at the cost of losing stability guarantees and controller interpretability. In this paper, we examine the utility of extending PID controllers with recurrent neural networks—–namely, General Dynamic Neural Networks (GDNN); we show that GDNN (neural) PID controllers perform well on a range of complex control systems and highlight how they can be a scalable and interpretable option for modern control systems. To do so, we provide an extensive study using four benchmark systems that represent the most common control engineering benchmarks. All control environments are evaluated with and without noise as well as with and without disturbances. The neural PID controller performs better than standard PID control in 15 of 16 tasks and better than model-based control in 13 of 16 tasks. As a second contribution, we address the lack of interpretability that prevents neural networks from being used in real-world control processes. We use bounded-input bounded-output stability analysis to evaluate the parameters suggested by the neural network, making them understandable for engineers. This combination of rigorous evaluation paired with better interpretability is an important step towards the acceptance of neural-network-based control approaches for real-world systems. It is furthermore an important step towards interpretable and safely applied artificial intelligence.

A New PID Neural Network Controller Design for Nonlinear Processes

A multivariable nonlinear self-tuning PID controller

Single neuron predictive pid control

Neuron Variable Structural PID Control Scheme for Nonlinear Plants

PID Parameters Auto-Tuning Method for Industrial Temperature Adjustment

A Pid Controller With Neuron Tuning Parameters For Multi-Model Plants

Neural network based iterative learning predictive control design for mechatronic systems with isolated nonlinearity

Self-learning Fuzzy PID Controller Based on Neural Networks

On PID Controllers Based on Simulated Annealing Algorithm

Nonlinear Predictive Control With Error Compensation Based On Neural Network

Neuron Model-Free Pid Control

Deterministic Learning-Based Neural PID Control for Nonlinear Robotic Systems

An improved control strategy of single neuron PID

A Novel Auto-Tuning Robust Pid Controller for Networked Control System

PID parameter self-tuning and robust control based on neural networks

Data Driven PID-type Neural Network Controller Design Using Lazy Learning for CSTR

Intelligent PID Controller Design with Adaptive Criterion Adjustment Via Least Squares Support Vector Machine

Automatic tuning of PID controllers using deep recurrent neural networks with pruning based on tracking error

Interpretable PID parameter tuning for control engineering using general dynamic neural networks: An extensive comparison

Neural Network-Based Optimal Iterative Controller for Nonlinear Processes

A Study on PID Intelligent Optimization Based on Radial Basis Function Neural Networks