Abstract:The consensus of soil fertility specialists working in the northeast USA was that soil testing and recommendation systems for P needed to be reexamined because of recent changes in soil testing methodology in the laboratory and corn ( Zea mays L.) production technology in the field. Soil tests (M‐COL, MM‐COL, B‐ICP, M1‐ICP, and M3‐ICP) were performed by either colorimetry or inductively coupled plasma (ICP) emission spectroscopy on samples from soil test calibration studies conducted during 1998 to 1999 at 51 experimental sites chosen to represent a range of soils, including Ultisols, Spodosols, and Alfisols, in northeastern states (Connecticut, Delaware, Massachusetts, Maryland, Maine, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, and West Virginia). The mean P measured by M‐COL, MM‐COL, B‐ICP, M1‐ICP, and M3‐ICP was 8.3, 6.6, 148, 66, and 121 mg P kg −1 , respectively. Production practices followed local state extension recommendations at each site and included P fertilizer treatments: none, 15 kg P ha −1 banded, or 60 kg P ha −1 broadcast. Combined analysis of variance over sites showed that plant height at 35 d after planting, silk emergence, grain yield, and grain dry down were enhanced by the broadcast P treatment. There were yield increases ( P < 0.10) to the band treatment at only four sites and to the broadcast treatment at nine sites. Cate‐Nelson statistical analysis of relative yield in relation to soil test P failed to identify soil test P critical levels for any of the soil test methods. The percentage of experimental sites that had soil test P levels below the currently used critical levels in the region ranged from 14 to 65% of the sites. Results showed that 17 to 47% of those sites testing below the critical level exhibited a yield increase ( P < 0.10) to broadcast P. Some of the yield responsive sites had soil test P above currently used critical levels. The calibration data obtained from the present study and the relationships examined between soil test P and relative yield do not necessarily validate the currently used soil test P critical levels nor does the data enable much refinement. This study shows that the current critical levels frequently permit both types of errors in soil test prediction; indicating a need for P fertilization when it may not be needed and not indicating a need for P fertilization when it may be needed. The second type of error is usually avoided by recommendations for crop removal rates of P.

Calibrating Corn Color from Aerial Photographs to Predict Sidedress Nitrogen Need

On-farm Assessment of Nitrogen Fertilizer Application to Corn on Nitrous Oxide Emissions

Estimating rice chlorophyll content and leaf nitrogen concentration with a digital still color camera under natural light

Active‐Optical Reflectance Sensing Corn Algorithms Evaluated over the United States Midwest Corn Belt

Using Optimized Three-Band Spectral Indices to Assess Canopy N Uptake in Corn and Wheat

Active-Optical Sensors Using Red NDVI Compared to Red Edge NDVI for Prediction of Corn Grain Yield in North Dakota, U.S.A.

Modeling Long-Term Corn Yield Response to Nitrogen Rate and Crop Rotation

Integrating plant morphological traits with remote-sensed multispectral imageries for accurate corn grain yield prediction

Corn Nitrogen Nutrition Index Prediction Improved by Integrating Genetic, Environmental, and Management Factors with Active Canopy Sensing Using Machine Learning

Soil Test Calibration for Predicting Corn Response to Phosphorus in the Northeast USA

Contrasting corn yield responses to nitrogen fertilization in southeast coastal plain soils

Evaluation of Soil Properties, Topographic Metrics, Plant Height, and Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Multispectral Imagery Using Machine Learning Methods to Estimate Canopy Nitrogen Weight in Corn

Comparison of Satellite Remote Sensing and Aerial Photography for Ability to Detect In-Season Nitrogen Stress in Corn

Evaluation of Vegetation Indices for Early Assessment of Corn Status and Yield Potential in the Southeastern United States

Optical Sensor‐Based Algorithm for Crop Nitrogen Fertilization

A Methodology for the Detection of Nitrogen Deficiency in Corn Fields Using High-Resolution RGB Imagery

Machine Learning in Evaluating Multispectral Active Canopy Sensor for Prediction of Corn Leaf Nitrogen Concentration and Yield

Multispectral Image Sensor for Detection of Nitrogen Deficiency in Corn by Using an Empirical Line Method

Rationale for Optimum Nitrogen Fertilization in Corn Production