Persistence solves Fermi Paradox but challenges SETI projects

Osame Kinouchi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0112137
2001-12-09
Abstract:Persistence phenomena in colonization processes could explain the negative results of SETI search preserving the possibility of a galactic civilization. However, persistence phenomena also indicates that search of technological civilizations in stars in the neighbourhood of Sun is a misdirected SETI strategy. This last conclusion is also suggested by a weaker form of the Fermi paradox. A simple model of a branching colonization which includes emergence, decay and branching of civilizations is proposed. The model could also be used in the context of ant nests diffusion.
Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The problems the paper attempts to solve This paper attempts to explain the Fermi Paradox by introducing the "persistence" phenomenon and challenges the existing strategies of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) projects. #### Background and problem description The core problem of the Fermi Paradox is: if there are many advanced civilizations in the Milky Way that are capable of interstellar colonization, why haven't we found any traces of them so far? The traditional Fermi Paradox hypothesis assumes that a technological civilization can spread throughout the Milky Way in about 100 million years. However, in reality, we haven't observed the existence of these civilizations, which has led to doubts about whether such a galactic civilization exists. #### Main points 1. **Persistence phenomenon**: - Persistence refers to the fact that in some diffusion processes, the rate at which the number of unvisited or uncolonized locations decays over time is not exponential but follows a power - law distribution. The specific formula is: \[ P(t) = P_{\infty} + C t^{-\theta} \] where \(P_{\infty}\) is the asymptotic probability, \(C\) is a constant, \(t\) represents time, and \(\theta\) is the persistence index. - This means that even in an infinite amount of time, there is still a non - zero probability that some locations have never been visited. Therefore, the Earth may be a persistent location, that is, a place that has not been visited by an alien civilization. 2. **Challenges to SETI project strategies**: - The persistence phenomenon indicates that searching for alien civilizations in star systems near the Sun may be ineffective. Because if there were technological civilizations near these stars, they should have already colonized the Earth. - Therefore, the paper suggests that SETI should shift its search focus to more distant star systems, star clusters, or neighboring galaxies to look for radio, laser, or neutrino signals as well as artificial features. 3. **The uniqueness of human civilization**: - The paper points out that the Earth may be located in a large but sparsely populated galactic region, similar to some remote areas on Earth (such as the Amazon forest, the Indonesian archipelago, etc.). In this case, the Earth is not a typical galactic location but a persistent location that has not been visited by the galactic colonization process. #### Conclusion By introducing the persistence phenomenon, the paper provides a new explanatory framework that does not rely on unverifiable sociological assumptions (such as the zoo hypothesis) and is also consistent with the existing SETI search results. At the same time, the paper suggests re - evaluating the search strategies of SETI projects to avoid wasting time and resources on neighboring star systems. In summary, this paper aims to explain the Fermi Paradox through the persistence phenomenon and proposes suggestions for improving the search strategies of SETI projects.