Abstract:Results obtained in two recent papers, \cite{Kaszlikowski} and \cite{Durt}, seem to indicate that the nonlocal character of the correlations between the outcomes of measurements performed on entangled systems separated in space is not robust in the presence of noise. This is surprising, since entanglement itself is robust. Here we revisit this problem and argue that the class of gedanken-experiments considered in \cite{Kaszlikowski} and \cite{Durt} is too restrictive. By considering a more general class, involving sequences of measurements, we prove that the nonlocal correlations are in fact robust.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the nonlocal correlations in quantum entanglement systems are still robust in the presence of noise. Specifically, previous studies [1] and [2] showed that when a certain proportion of noise is added to the maximally entangled state, the nonlocal correlations seem to become no longer robust, that is, when a noise threshold (about \( F_N \approx 0.33 \)) is exceeded, these states no longer produce nonlocal correlations. This is in contrast to the robustness of entanglement itself, because even under high - noise conditions, the entangled states of some high - dimensional systems still remain entangled.
The author believes that this conclusion may be due to the fact that the previous experimental settings were too limited, only considering single - von - Neumann measurements and ignoring more complex measurement sequences. Therefore, the main problem of this paper can be summarized as:
**How to prove that quantum nonlocal correlations are still robust in a noisy environment?**
To answer this question, the author introduced a new class of "gedanken - experiments", which involve a series of measurements rather than a single measurement. Through this method, the author attempts to show that even when there is a high proportion of noise, some quantum states can still produce nonlocal correlations.
### Main contributions
1. **Re - evaluating the robustness of nonlocality**:
- The author points out that previous experiments were limited to single - time measurements and failed to fully reveal all the characteristics of nonlocality.
2. **Introducing a multi - step measurement scheme**:
- The author proposes a method involving multi - step measurements, showing that in this case, even under high - noise conditions, some quantum states can still produce nonlocal correlations.
3. **Mathematical proof**:
- Through specific mathematical derivations, the author proves that for a sufficiently large \( N \), even under high - noise conditions, some quantum states can still violate Bell's inequality and thus exhibit nonlocality. For example, when the noise proportion \( F_N < \frac{N}{N + c} \) (where \( c = 2\sqrt{2}-1\approx 4.83 \)), nonlocal correlations still exist.
### Conclusion
The author finally proves the robustness of nonlocal correlations in a noisy environment and points out the direction for future research. In particular, whether the quantum states that still remain entangled but do not violate Bell's inequality in noisy conditions really do not possess nonlocality is still an open question.
In this way, the author not only resolves the previous contradiction but also provides new ideas and methods for further research on quantum nonlocality.