Abstract:The existence of true scale-invariance in slowly driven models of self-organized criticality without a conservation law, as forest-fires or earthquake automata, is scrutinized in this paper. By using three different levels of description - (i) a simple mean field, (ii) a more detailed mean-field description in terms of a (self-organized) branching processes, and (iii) a full stochastic representation in terms of a Langevin equation-, it is shown on general grounds that non-conserving dynamics does not lead to bona fide criticality. Contrarily to conserving systems, a parameter, which we term "re-charging" rate (e.g. the tree-growth rate in forest-fire models), needs to be fine-tuned in non-conserving systems to obtain criticality. In the infinite size limit, such a fine-tuning of the loading rate is easy to achieve, as it emerges by imposing a second separation of time-scales but, for any finite size, a precise tuning is required to achieve criticality and a coherent finite-size scaling picture. Using the approaches above, we shed light on the common mechanisms by which "apparent criticality" is observed in non-conserving systems, and explain in detail (both qualitatively and quantitatively) the difference with respect to true criticality obtained in conserving systems. We propose to call this self-organized quasi-criticality (SOqC). Some of the reported results are already known and some of them are new. We hope the unified framework presented here helps to elucidate the confusing and contradictory literature in this field. In a second accompanying paper, we shall discuss the implications of the general results obtained here for models of neural avalanches in Neuroscience for which self-organized scale-invariance in the absence of conservation has been claimed.

The self-organized critical forest-fire model on large scales

Universality in the One-Dimensional Self-Organized Critical Forest-Fire Model

Self-Organized Criticality and Synchronization in the Forest-Fire Model

Critical Behaviour of the Drossel-Schwabl Forest Fire Model

A forest-fire model and some thoughts on turbulence

Influences of Finite-Size Effects on the Self-Organized Criticality of Forest-Fire Model

Crossover from percolation to self-organized criticality

Anomalous criticality coexists with giant cluster in the uniform forest model

Forest-Fire Model with Resistant Trees

Forest Fire Model as a Supercritical Dynamic Model in Financial Systems

Forest Fire Model with Two Species of Trees

Self-organization without conservation: true or just apparent scale-invariance?

Well-posedness of the mean field forest fire age evolution equation

Self-Similarity and Scaling in Forest Communities

Weather-driven Model Indicative of Spatiotemporal Power Laws.

Critical dynamics of the Kuramoto model on sparse random networks

Forest fire spreading: A nonlinear stochastic model continuous in space and time

Cluster growth in the dynamical Erdős-Rényi process with forest fires

Two-dimensional forest fires with boundary ignitions

Analytical and numerical insights into wildfire dynamics: Exploring the advection–diffusion–reaction model