Abstract:Background: Electrocardiography (ECG) is a fundamental diagnostic tool, frequently used in clinical practice, for testing heart conditions. Recently, computer-aided ECG interpretation has become more widely investigated. However, researches on concurrent ECG diagnosis for multiple heart abnormalities are limited and therefore a market-applicable multi-label automatic diagnosis framework that covers a wide range of arrhythmias, with better-than-human accuracy in diagnosing ECGs with multi-labels, has not yet been developed. We therefore aimed to engineer a deep learning approach for the automated multi-label diagnosis of impulse or conduction abnormalities by realtime ECG analysis. Methods: We utilized a dataset with 70,692 patients, consisting of adults with age ≥18 years. 180112 ECGs (standard 10-second and 12-lead format) with 21 distinct rhythm classes, including various impulse or conduction abnormalities, were used for the diagnosis of arrhythmias in multi-label and single-label level. Base rhythm labels were assessed by trained personnel under the supervision of cardiologists. We ensured that each abnormality had a sample size of at least 4,000 ECGs, except idioventricular rhythm (1,780 ECGs due to the rarity of said disease), for compiling a balanced dataset. We allocated ECGs to a training or a validation dataset for the multi-label diagnostic model training, and evaluated model performance on a test dataset by calculating the area under the curve (AUC) of the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve, as well as quantifying accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and the F1 score. The test dataset was annotated by the consensus of a committee of board-certified actively-practicing cardiologists. Validation of results for the test dataset were compared to diagnoses made by 53 ECG cardiologists who have a wide range of ECG interpretation experience (range=0-12+ years). Findings: We demonstrated that in multi-label level, our convolutional neural network (CNN) approach toward diagnosing heart abnormalities resulted in AUC scores above 0.913 for most of the diseases, with an average score of 0.985 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.988-0.994). The model obtained an average F1 score of 0.890 (95% CI0.877- 0.903), sensitivity of 0.869 (95% CI 0.851-0.887), specificity of 0.995 (95% CI 0.994- 0.996). The average F1 score computed from our deep learning model exceeded the score from human cardiologists regardless of ECG interpretation experience (0 < Y ≤ 6 years: 0.788, 6 < Y ≤ 12 years: 0.815, Y > 12 years: 0.829). The CNN outputs also showed identical or increased performance with respect to average sensitivity and accuracy as compared to the cardiologists. In single-label level, the CNN achieved an average F1 of 0.918, higher than the average level of the cardiologists 0.798. Interpretation: Our automatic ECG diagnosis system is better than human cardiologists to classify particular waveforms into clinically defined categories accurately, to distinguish a wide range of distinct arrhythmias, and to apply both single label and multiple label ECGs. Our study is therefore a promising foundation for the deployment of computational decision-support systems in practical clinical applications.Funding Statement: Project supported by the Major International (Regional) Joint Research Project, the Ministry of Management Science, the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 71520107003).Declaration of Interests: Dr. Yuan reports grants from National Natural Science Foundation of China, during the conduct of the study; In addition, Dr. Yuan has a patent An automatic ECG classification method, system and equipment based on deep learning algorithm pending to Ye Yuan, Xiaoyun Yang, Hongling Zhu, Yiran Wang, Cheng Cheng, Xingyi Li, Hang Yin, Jingyi Wang. There are no other conflicts of interest.Ethics Approval Statement: To protect patients’ privacy, we used anonymized data as to prevent breaches. Accordingly, a written informed consent was not required for this study, since the ECG samples were appropriately anonymized and de-identified, as according to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act Safe Harbor provision. The study design was evaluated and exempted from full review by the Huazhong University of Science and Technology Institutional Review Board.

Do Single Beat ECGs have Same Credibility as Continuous ECG Signal in Multi-Class Classification using Machine Learning Models

Comparative Analysis of Machine Learning Algorithms With Advanced Feature Extraction for ECG Signal Classification

Automated Heartbeat Classification Exploiting Convolutional Neural Network with Channel-Wise Attention

Multi-label Classification of Abnormalities in 12-Lead ECG Using Deep Learning.

rECGnition_v1.0: Arrhythmia detection using cardiologist-inspired multi-modal architecture incorporating demographic attributes in ECG

Exploring a new frontier in cardiac diagnosis: ECG analysis enhanced by machine learning and parametric quartic spline modeling

Electrocardiogram (ECG) Based Cardiac Arrhythmia Detection and Classification using Machine Learning Algorithms

Short-term atrial fibrillation detection using electrocardiograms: A comparison of machine learning approaches

A novel application of deep learning for single-lead ECG classification

Scalable and Upgradable AI for Detected Beat-By-Beat ECG Signals in Smart Health

ECG arrhythmia detection in an inter-patient setting using Fourier decomposition and machine learning

ECG-CL: A Comprehensive Electrocardiogram Interpretation Method Based on Continual Learning

Imbalanced ECG signal-based heart disease classification using ensemble machine learning technique

Automatic Multi-Label ECG Diagnosis of Impulse or Conduction Abnormalities in Patients with Deep Learning Algorithm: A Cohort Study

IMLE-Net: An Interpretable Multi-level Multi-channel Model for ECG Classification

Optimization of Using Multiple Machine Learning Approaches in Atrial Fibrillation Detection Based on a Large-Scale Data Set of 12-Lead Electrocardiograms: Cross-Sectional Study

Abstract 19135: Deep Learning Model for Detection of Conduction Disorders and Arrhythmias From PDF Outputs of Commercially Available Wearable Devices

Certain Examination on ECG Classification using Hybrid Machine Learning Models

An Arrhythmia classification approach via deep learning using single-lead ECG without QRS wave detection

Deep learning models for multilabel ECG abnormalities classification: A comparative study using TPE optimization

Arrhythmia classification for non-experts using infinite impulse response (IIR)-filter-based machine learning and deep learning models of the electrocardiogram