Effects of space charge force on the beam-beam mode coupling instability

Kazuhito Ohmi and Yuan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevaccelbeams.27.101001

2024-10-19

Physical Review Accelerators and Beams

Abstract:In e+e- colliders beam-beam mode coupling instability can be stabilized with space charge. [Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 27, 101001] Published Fri Oct 18, 2024

physics, particles & fields, nuclear

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Beam-beam effects in space charge dominated ion beams

C. Montag,A. Fedotov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5170/CERN-2014-004.63

2014-10-15

Abstract:During low-energy operations below the regular injection energy in the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC), significant beam lifetime reductions due to the beam-beam interaction in conjunction with large space charge tune shifts have been observed. We report on dedicated experiments aimed at understanding this phenomenon as well as preliminary simulation results, and propose alternative working points to improve the beam lifetime in future lowenergy RHIC runs.

Accelerator Physics
Theoretical elucidation of space charge effects on the coupled-bunch instability at the 3 GeV rapid cycling synchrotron at the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex

Yoshihiro Shobuda,Yong Ho Chin,Pranab Kumar Saha,Hideaki Hotchi,Hiroyuki Harada,Yoshiro Irie,Fumihiko Tamura,Norio Tani,Takeshi Toyama,Yasuhiro Watanabe,Masanobu Yamamoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ptep/ptw169

2017-01-01

Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics

Abstract:The Rapid Cycling Synchrotron (RCS), whose beam energy ranges from 400 MeV to 3 GeV and which is located in the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex, is a kicker-impedance-dominated machine, which violates the impedance budget from a classical viewpoint. Contrary to conventional understanding, we have succeeded in accelerating a 1 MW equivalent beam. The machine has some interesting features: e.g., the beam tends to be unstable for the smaller transverse beam size and the beam is stabilized by increasing the peak current. Space charge effects play an important role in the beam instability at the RCS. In this study, a new theory has been developed to calculate the beam growth rate with the head-tail and coupled-bunch modes (m,μ) while taking space charge effects into account. The theory sufficiently explains the distinctive features of the beam instabilities at the RCS.

physics, multidisciplinary, particles & fields
Stabilizing influence of axial momentum spread on the two-stream instability in intense heavy ion beams

Ronald C. Davidson,Hong Qin,Igor Kaganovich,W.Wei-li Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0168-9002(01)00117-6

2001-01-01

Abstract:This paper makes use of the Vlasov–Maxwell equations to describe the electron–ion two-stream instability driven by the directed axial motion of a high-intensity ion beam propagating through a stationary population of (unwanted) background electrons in the acceleration region or beam transport lines. The ion beam is treated as continuous in the z-direction, and the electrons are electrostatically confined in the transverse direction by the space-charge potential produced by the excess ion charge. The analysis is carried out for arbitrary beam intensity, consistent with transverse confinement of the beam particles, and arbitrary fractional charge neutralization by the background electrons. For the case of overlapping step-function ion and electron density profiles, corresponding to Kapchinskij–Vladimirskij (KV) electron and ion distributions in the transverse direction, detailed stability properties are calculated including parallel kinetic effects over a wide range of system parameters for dipole perturbations with azimuthal mode number ℓ=1. The instability growth rate is found to increase with increasing beam intensity, increasing fractional charge neutralization, and decreasing proximity of the conducting wall. For space-charge-dominated beams, it is shown that Landau damping associated with a modest axial momentum spread of the beam ions and background electrons has a strong stabilizing influence on the two-stream instability.
Anisotropy-Driven Instability in Intense Charged Particle Beams

EA Startsev,RC Davidson,H Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/pac.2005.1590493

2005-01-01

Physical Review Special Topics - Accelerators and Beams

Abstract:We have generalized the analysis of the classical Harris instability to the case of a one-component intense charged particle beam with anisotropic temperature including the important effects of finite transverse geometry and beam space-charge. For a long, coasting beam, the delta-f particle-in-cell code BEST and the eighenmode code bEASt have been used to determine detailed 3D stability properties over a wide range of temperature anisotropy and beam intensity. A theoretical model is developed based on the Vlasov-Maxwell equations which describes the essential features of the linear stage of this instability. Both the simulations and the analytical theory clearly show that moderately intense beams are linearly unstable to short-wavelength perturbations provided the ratio of the longitudinal temperature to the transverse temperature is smaller than some threshold value.
Analytic Model for the Breakup of A Coasting Beam with Space Charge in Isochronous Accelerators

Yuanjie Bi,Tianjue Zhang,Chuanxiang Tang,Yongsheng Huang,Jianjun Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3340865

IF: 2.877

2010-01-01

Journal of Applied Physics

Abstract:An analytical model based on the negative mass instability is introduced in this paper to explain the formation of the breakup of a coasting beam into small clusters in isochronous machines such as the case observed by Pozdeyev and Rodriguez in a small isochronous ring. Solving Poisson's equation in both charge and vacuum regions with the longitudinal beam density perturbation, the coherent radial space charge force which decreases the transition gamma is obtained. It is found that the modified transition gamma depends on the wave number of the density perturbation, longitudinal beam density distribution, beam intensity, and beam size. By combining the longitudinal space charge force caused by the perturbation and the modified transition gamma, a dispersion relation for a monoenergetic beam is derived and evaluated for the fastest-growing instability mode in terms of the beam parameters, such as energy, bunch length, intensity, and emittance. The fastest-growing negative mass mode number, which determines not only the cluster number but also the growth rate of the instability, is proportional to the orbit radius and inversely proportional to the initial beam size. With the growth of the instability, the particles at the points of local minimum density move to the ones of local maximum density, with the transition gamma increasing. Since the growth rate depends on the longitudinal density distribution, therefore, instead of a constant growth rate, our model shows that the growth rate decreases with time. The results above can be applied to both short and long wavelength limits. As an important application of this theory, the beam breakup effect in the isochronous cyclotron CYCIAE-100 is predicted.
Landau Damping with Electron Lenses in Space-Charge Dominated Beams

Yuri Alexahin,Alexey Burov,Vladimir Shiltsev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1709.10020

2017-09-28

Abstract:Progress on the Intensity Frontier of high energy physics critically depends on record high intensity charged particles accelerators. Beams in such machines become operationally limited by coherent beam instabilities, particularly enhanced in the regime of strong space charge (SC). Usual methods to control the instabilities, such as octupole magnets, beam feedback dampers and employment of chromatic effects, become less effective and insufficient. In [1] it was proposed to employ electron lenses for introduction of sufficient spread in particle oscillation frequencies needed for beam stabilization and in [2] it was shown that electron lenses are uniquely effective for Landau damping of transverse beam instabilities in high energy particle accelerators and their employment does not compromise incoherent (single particle) stability, dynamic aperture and the beam lifetime. Here we consider an important issue of effectiveness of the Landau damping with electron lenses in space-charge dominated beams and demonstrate that the desired stability can be assured with proper choice of the electron beam parameters and current distributions.

Accelerator Physics
Effects on Axial Momentum Spread on the Electron-Ion Two-Stream Instability in High-Intensity Ion Beams

R. Davidso,H. Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2172/756590

2000-01-01

Abstract:Use is made of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations to describe the electron-ion two-stream instability driven by the directed axial motion of a high-intensity ion beam propagating through a stationary population of (unwanted) background electrons. The ion beam is treated as continuous in the z-direction, and the electrons are electrostatically confined in the transverse direction by the space-charge potential produced by the excession charge. The analysis is carried out for arbitrary beam intensity, consistent with transverse confinement of the beam particles, and arbitrary fractional charge neutralization by the background electrons. For the case of overlapping step-function ion and electron density profiles, corresponding to monoenergetic electrons and ions in the transverse direction, detailed stability properties are calculated, including the important effects of an axial momentum spread, over a wide range of system parameters for dipole perturbations with azimuthal mode number l=1. The two-stream instability growth rate is found to increase with increasing beam intensity, increasing fractional charge neutralization, and decreasing proximity of the conducting wall. It is shown that Landau damping associated with a modest axial momentum spread of the beam ions and background electrons has a strong stabilizing influence on the instability.
3D Simulation Studies of the Two-Stream Instability in Intense Particle Beams Based on the Vlasov-Maxwell Equations

Hong Qin,Davidson, R.C.,Startsev, E.,Lee, W.W.L.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/pac.2001.987607

2001-01-01

Abstract:Two-stream instabilities in intense charged particle beams, described self-consistently by the nonlinear Vlasov-Maxwell equations, are studied using a 3D multispecies perturbative particle simulation method. The newly developed beam equilibrium, stability, and transport (BEST) code is used to simulate the linear and nonlinear properties of the electron-proton (e-p) two-stream instability observed in the Proton Storage Ring (PSR) experiment for a long coasting beam. Simulations in a parameter regime characteristic of the PSR experiment show that the e-p instability has a dipole-mode structure, and that the instability threshold descreases with increasing fractional neutralization, and increases with increasing axial momentum spread of the beam particles. In the nonlinear phase, the simulations show that the instability first saturates at a relatively low level, and subsequently grows to a higher level
Effects of axial momentum spread on the electron–ion two-stream instability in high-intensity ion beams

Ronald C. Davidson,Hong Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9601(00)00296-6

IF: 2.707

2000-01-01

Physics Letters A

Abstract:Use is made of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations to describe the electron-ion two-stream instability driven by the directed axial motion of a high-intensity ion beam propagating through a stationary population of (unwanted) background electrons. The ion beam is treated as continuous in the z-direction, and the electrons are electrostatically confined in the transverse direction by the space-charge potential produced by the excess ion charge. The analysis is carried out for arbitrary beam intensity, consistent with transverse confinement of the beam particles, and arbitrary fractional charge neutralization by the background electrons. For the case of overlapping step-function ion and electron density profiles, corresponding to monoenergetic electrons and ions in the transverse direction, detailed stability properties are calculated, including the important effects of an axial momentum spread, over a wide range of system parameters for dipole perturbations with azimuthal mode number l=1. The two-stream instability growth rate is found to increase with increasing beam intensity, increasing fractional charge neutralization, and decreasing proximity of the conducting wall. It is shown that Landau damping associated with a modest axial momentum spread of the beam ions and background electrons has a strong stabilizing influence on the instability. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Collisional Effects on the Oblique Instability in Relativistic Beam-Plasma Interactions

B. Hao,W. J. Ding,Z. M. Sheng,C. Ren,X. Kong,J. Mu,J. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4736980

IF: 2.2

2012-01-01

Physics of Plasmas

Abstract:The general oblique instability for a relativistic electron beam propagating through a warm and resistive plasma is investigated fully kinetically by a variable rotation method. Analysis shows that the electrostatic part of the oblique instability is attenuated and eventually stabilized by collisional effects. However, the electromagnetic part of the oblique instability (EMOI) is enhanced. Since the current-filamentation instability as a special case of the EMOI has a larger growth rate, it becomes dominant in the collisional case as shown in our two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations. While the beam diverges in the collisionless case, it can become magnetically collimated in the collisional case due to stabilization of the electrostatic instabilities when the initial beam spreading angle is less than certain magnitude such as a dozen degrees. (C) 2012 American Institute of Physics. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.4736980]
Experimental Studies on the Photoelectron Instability in the Beijing Electron Positron Collider

ZY Guo,H Huang,SP Li,DK Liu,L Ma,Q Qin,JQ Wang,SH Wang,G Xu,C Zhang,Z Zhao,YH Chin,H Fukuma,S Hiramatsu,M Izawa,T Kasuga,E Kikutani,Y Kobayashi,S Kurokawa,K Ohmi,Y Sato,Y Suetsugu,M Tobiyama,K Tsukamoto,K Yokoya,XL Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevstab.5.124403

2002-01-01

Physical Review Special Topics - Accelerators and Beams

Abstract:A vertical coupled-bunch instability was observed for a positron beam at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPC). The experimental results show that the instability has similar characteristics as that observed in the Photon Factory of KEK several years ago. The instability at BEPC can be explained by the effect of an electron cloud which is produced in the beam chamber by synchrotron light hitting the wall.
Nonlinear Perturbative Particle Simulation Studies of the Electron-Proton Two-Stream Instability in High Intensity Proton Beams

H Qin,EA Startsev,RC Davidson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevstab.6.014401

2003-01-01

Physical Review Special Topics - Accelerators and Beams

Abstract:Two-stream instabilities in intense charged particle beams, described self-consistently by the nonlinear Vlasov-Maxwell equations, are studied using a 3D multispecies perturbative particle simulation method. The recently developed Beam Equilibrium, Stability and Transport code is used to simulate the linear and nonlinear properties of the electron-proton (e-p) two-stream instability observed in the Proton Storage Ring (PSR) experiment for a long, coasting beam. Simulations in a parameter regime characteristic of the PSR experiment show that the e-p instability has a dipole-mode structure, and that the growth rate is an increasing function of beam intensity, but a decreasing function of the longitudinal momentum spread. It is also shown that the instability threshold decreases with increasing fractional charge neutralization and increases with increasing axial momentum spread of the beam particles. In the nonlinear phase, the simulations show that the proton density perturbation first saturates at a relatively low level and subsequently grows to a higher level. Finally, the nonlinear space-charge-induced transverse tune spread, which introduces a major growth-rate reduction effect on the e-p instability, is studied for self-consistent equilibrium populations of protons and electrons.
Beam-beam Blowup in the presence of x-y coupling sources at FCC-ee

Dima El Khechen,Katsunobu Oide,Frank Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1904.10306

2019-04-23

Abstract:FCC-ee, the lepton version of the Future Circular Collider (FCC), is a 100 Km future machine under study to be built at CERN. It acquires two experiments with a highest beam energy of 182.5 GeV. FCC-ee aims to operate at four different energies, with different luminosities to fulfil physics requirements. Beam-beam effects at such a high energy/luminosity machine are very challenging and require a deep understanding, especially in the presence of x-y coupling sources. Beam-beam effects include the beamstrahlung process, which limits the beam lifetime at high energies, as well as dynamic effects at the Interaction point (IP) which include changes in the beta functions and emittances. In this report, we will define the beam-beam effects and their behaviours in the FCC-ee highest energy lattice after introducing x-y coupling in the ring.

Accelerator Physics
Beam-beam effects in BEPCII

Y. Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1410.4057

2014-10-15

Accelerator Physics

Abstract:We first introduce the design parameters of the Beijing Electron-Positron Collider II (BEPCII) and the simulation study of beam-beam effects during the design process of the machine. The main advances since 2007 are briefly introduced and reviewed. The longitudinal feedback system was installed to suppress the coupled bunch instability in January 2010. The horizontal tune decreased from 6.53 to 6.508 during the course of data taken in December, 2010. The saturation of the beam-beam parameter was found in 2011, and the vacuum chambers and magnets near the north crossing point were moved 15 cm in order to mitigate the long range beam-beam interaction. At the beginning of 2013, the beam-beam parameter achieved 0.04 with the new lower $\alpha_{p}$ lattice and the peak luminosity achieved 7 x 10$^{32}$ cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$.
Collective Temperature Anisotropy Instabilities in Intense Charged Particle Beams

EA Startsev,RC Davidson,H Qin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2436847

IF: 2.2

2007-01-01

Physics of Plasmas

Abstract:The classical electrostatic Harris instability and the electromagnetic Weibel instability, both driven by a large temperature anisotropy (T‖b∕T⊥b⪡1) that develops naturally in accelerators, are generalized to the case of a one-component intense charged particle beam with anisotropic temperature, including the important effects of finite transverse geometry and beam space-charge. Such instabilities may lead to an increase in the longitudinal velocity spread, which makes focusing the beam difficult, and may impose a limit on the beam luminosity and the minimum spot size achievable in focusing experiments. This paper describes recent advances in the theory and simulation of collective instabilities in intense charged particle beams caused by large temperature anisotropy. The new simulation tools that have been developed to study these instabilities are also described. Results of the investigations that identify the instability growth rates, levels of saturations, and conditions for quiescent beam propagation are also discussed.
Studies of the beam-ion instability and its mitigation with feedback system

Chao Li,Saike Tian,Na Wang,Haisheng Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.23.074401

2019-11-14

Abstract:The beam-ion interaction is a potential limitation of beam performance in electron accelerators, especially where the beam emittance is of a great concern in future ultra-low emittance light source. "Conventionally", the beam instability due to beam-ion interaction is attributed to two types of effects: ion trapping effect and fast ion effect, which emphasize the beam-ion dynamics in different time scales. Whereas, in accelerators, the beam suffers from a mixture of ion trapping effect and fast ion effect, leading to a more complicated process and requiring a self-consistent treatment. To evaluate the beam characteristics, as emittance growth under the influence from beam-ion effect, a new numerical simulation code based on the "quasi-strong-strong" model has been developed, including modules of ionization, beam-ion interaction, synchrotron radiation damping, quantum excitation, bunch-by-bunch feedback, etc. In the study, we do not regularly distinguish the ion trapping effect and the fast ion effect, but treat beam-ion interaction more generally and consistently. The lattice of High Energy Photon Source, a diffraction limit ring under construction in Beijing, is used as an example to show the beam-ion effect. It is found that in this low emittance ring, the beam-ion instability is not a dominant mechanism in operation mode with a high beam current, but seriously occurs in a lower beam current region. When the beam-ion instability were significantly driven and can not be damped by the synchrotron radiation damping, the simulations show the bunch-by-bunch feedback system based on the Finite Impulse Response filter technique can be adopted to mitigate it effectively.

Accelerator Physics
Measures to mitigate the coherent beam-beam instability at CEPC

Yuan Zhang,Na Wang,Chuntao Lin,Kazuhito Ohmi,Liwei Pan

2024-05-22

Abstract:Both horizontal and vertical coherent beam-beam instability are important issues at CEPC. The horizontal instability (X-Z instability) could be induced by beam-beam itself. In this paper we try to study the effect of chromaticity and resistive feedback by analysis and simulation. The vertical instability may be induced due to the combined effect of beam-beam interaction and vacuum impedance. Finite chromaticity and asymmetrical tunes have been proposed to suppress the vertical instability. Due to the further increase of impedance budget, we need to find more measures to mitigate the instability. The effect of resistive feedback and hourglass effect are evaluated by simulation.

Accelerator Physics
Study on Beam Photoelectron Instability in Bepc

ZY Guo,Q Qin,C Zhang,L Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0254-3052.2001.03.011

2001-01-01

Abstract:A beam photoelectron instability may arise in high energy storage rings when the multibunch positron beam interacts with the photoelectrons which are produced in the beam tube by synchrotron radiation. This instability gives rise to a big interest for the accelerator physicists in recent years as a new mechanism has been involved in this phenomenon study. It is very important for the particle factories as there are strong multi-bunch positron beams to be operated. The experimental observations art carried out in the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPC) under the cooperation between IHEP, China and KEK, Japan, and the simulation studies are presented in this paper.
Interplay of space charge, intrabeam scattering, and synchrotron radiation in the Compact Linear Collider damping rings

M. Zampetakis,F. Antoniou,F. Asvesta,H. Bartosik,and Y. Papaphilippou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevaccelbeams.27.064403

2024-06-13

Physical Review Accelerators and Beams

Abstract:Future ultralow emittance rings for e−/e+ colliders require extremely high beam brightness and can thus be limited by collective effects. In this paper, the interplay of effects such as synchrotron radiation, intrabeam scattering (IBS), and space charge in the vicinity of excited betatron resonances is assessed. In this respect, two algorithms were developed to simulate IBS and synchrotron radiation effects and integrated in the p y orbit tracking code, to be combined with its widely used space charge module. The impact of these effects on the achievable beam parameters of the Compact Linear Collider (CLIC) damping rings was studied, showing that synchrotron radiation damping mitigates the adverse effects of IBS and space charge induced resonance crossing. The studies include also a full dynamic simulation of the CLIC damping ring cycle starting from the injection beam parameters. It is demonstrated that a careful working point choice is necessary, in order to accommodate the transition from detuning induced by lattice nonlinearities to space-charge dominated detuning and thereby avoid excessive losses and emittance growth generated in the vicinity of strong resonances. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.27.064403 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society

physics, particles & fields, nuclear
Experimental Studies of Compensation of Beam-Beam Effects with Tevatron Electron Lenses

V.Shiltsev,Yu.Alexahin,K.Bishofberger,V.Kamerdzhiev,V.Parkhomchuk,V.Reva,N.Solyak,D.Wildman,X.-L. Zhang,F.Zimmermann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/10/4/043042

2008-02-05

Abstract:Applying the space-charge forces of a low-energy electron beam can lead to a significant improvement of the beam-particle lifetime limit arising from the beam-beam interaction in a high-energy collider [1]. In this article we present the results of various beam experiments with electron lenses, novel instruments developed for the beam-beam compensation at the Tevatron, which collides 980-GeV proton and antiproton beams. We study the dependencies of the particle betatron tunes on the electron beam current, energy and position; we explore the effects of electron-beam imperfections and noises; and we quantify the improvements of the high-energy beam intensity and the collider luminosity lifetime obtained by the action of the Tevatron Electron Lenses.

Accelerator Physics

Effects of space charge force on the beam-beam mode coupling instability

Beam-beam effects in space charge dominated ion beams

Theoretical elucidation of space charge effects on the coupled-bunch instability at the 3 GeV rapid cycling synchrotron at the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex

Stabilizing influence of axial momentum spread on the two-stream instability in intense heavy ion beams

Anisotropy-Driven Instability in Intense Charged Particle Beams

Analytic Model for the Breakup of A Coasting Beam with Space Charge in Isochronous Accelerators

Landau Damping with Electron Lenses in Space-Charge Dominated Beams

Effects on Axial Momentum Spread on the Electron-Ion Two-Stream Instability in High-Intensity Ion Beams

3D Simulation Studies of the Two-Stream Instability in Intense Particle Beams Based on the Vlasov-Maxwell Equations

Effects of axial momentum spread on the electron–ion two-stream instability in high-intensity ion beams

Collisional Effects on the Oblique Instability in Relativistic Beam-Plasma Interactions

Experimental Studies on the Photoelectron Instability in the Beijing Electron Positron Collider

Nonlinear Perturbative Particle Simulation Studies of the Electron-Proton Two-Stream Instability in High Intensity Proton Beams

Beam-beam Blowup in the presence of x-y coupling sources at FCC-ee

Beam-beam effects in BEPCII

Collective Temperature Anisotropy Instabilities in Intense Charged Particle Beams

Studies of the beam-ion instability and its mitigation with feedback system

Measures to mitigate the coherent beam-beam instability at CEPC

Study on Beam Photoelectron Instability in Bepc

Interplay of space charge, intrabeam scattering, and synchrotron radiation in the Compact Linear Collider damping rings

Experimental Studies of Compensation of Beam-Beam Effects with Tevatron Electron Lenses