Job creation in a low carbon transition to renewables and energy efficiency: a review of international evidence

Richard Hanna,Philip Heptonstall,Robert Gross

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-023-01440-y

IF: 6

2024-01-13

Sustainability Science

Abstract:In this paper, we present findings from a systematic review on job creation, quality, and skills, focusing on decarbonisation in the energy sector. We compare a range of gross job employment factors which indicate that overall, investment in renewable energy and energy efficiency can deliver more jobs than gas or coal power generation. In addition, we review a subset of recent studies which estimate the net employment effects of decarbonisation in the energy sector at a national scale, across various international contexts. These national studies largely agree that the most likely outcome over the next few decades is a modest net positive creation of jobs and moderate economic growth. In certain regions within these countries, jobs in fossil fuel industries may be lost faster than the pace at which low carbon energy sectors can offer new employment. There may be mismatches between regions where displaced workers live and where new opportunities become available, which may be a barrier to accepting alternative employment even if former workers have the requisite skills. In these cases national government transition plans are recommended, coordinated with local governments, to manage the impacts of displacement from carbon-intensive sectors and respond to the need to build a new low carbon workforce including through skills development and training. We highlight a lack of metrics and data in the literature on job quality, skills, and the geographic distribution of employment impacts in decarbonising energy systems, and these should be priority areas for further research.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how many job opportunities can be created during the low-carbon transition in the energy sector, particularly through renewable energy and energy efficiency improvements, the quality of these job opportunities, and the temporal and spatial distribution of these job opportunities in different countries and regions.

Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Number of Jobs**: Comparing the differences in job creation between renewable energy and energy efficiency improvements and traditional fossil fuel power generation, assessing whether the low-carbon transition can bring more job opportunities.
2. **Job Quality**: Analyzing the quality of job opportunities created by the low-carbon transition in terms of wages, job security, and skill requirements.
3. **Geographical and Temporal Distribution of Jobs**: Exploring the distribution of the impact of low-carbon transition strategies on employment at the national and regional levels, particularly the changes at different time stages.

Through a systematic review of international literature, the paper aims to provide policymakers with comprehensive evidence on the impact of the low-carbon transition on employment, to support more scientific and equitable policy decisions.