Navigating Sustainability: Revealing the Hidden Forces in Social–Ecological Systems

Julen Gonzalez-Redin,Iain J. Gordon,J. Gareth Polhill,Terence P. Dawson,Rosemary Hill

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16031132

IF: 3.9

2024-01-30

Sustainability

Abstract:During the 1992 Rio Conference, the sustainable development agenda envisioned a transformative change for the management of natural resources, where the well-being of human society would be enhanced through the sustainable use of natural capital. Several decades on, relentless economic growth persists at the expense of natural capital, as demonstrated by biodiversity decline, climate change and other environmental challenges. Why is this happening and what can be done about it? We present three agent-based models that explore the social, economic and governance factors driving (un)sustainability in complex social–ecological systems. Our modelling results reinforce the idea that the current economic system fails to safeguard the natural capital upon which it relies, leading to the prevailing decoupling between the economic and natural systems. In attempting to find solutions for such disjunction, our research shows that social–ecological systems are complex, dynamic and non-linear. Interestingly, results also reveal that there are common factors to most social–ecological systems that have the potential to improve or diminish sustainability: the role of financial entities and monetary debt; economic speculation; technological development and efficiency; long-term views, tipping point management and government interventions; and top-down and bottom-up conservation forces. These factors can play a dual role, as they can either undermine or enhance sustainability depending on their specific context and particular conditions. Therefore, the current economic system may not be inherently unsustainable, but rather specific economic mechanisms, decision-making processes and the complex links between economic and natural systems could be at the root of the problem. We argue that short- and medium-term sustainability can be achieved by implementing mechanisms that shift capitalist forces to support environmental conservation. Long-term sustainability, in contrast, requires a more profound paradigm shift: the full integration and accounting of externalities and natural capital into the economy.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the sustainability issues of socio-ecological systems and attempts to uncover the hidden forces that drive or hinder the sustainable development of these systems. The authors construct three agent-based models (ABM) to investigate the social, economic, and governance factors driving sustainability and unsustainability in complex socio-ecological systems.

The core issue of the paper is that the current economic system fails to protect the natural capital it depends on, leading to a disconnection between the economic system and the natural system. To find solutions, the research shows that socio-ecological systems are complex, dynamic, and characterized by nonlinearity. Additionally, the study identifies some universal factors that can improve or weaken the sustainability of most socio-ecological systems, such as the role of financial entities and monetary debt, economic speculation, technological development and efficiency, long-term perspectives, critical point management, government intervention, and top-down versus bottom-up protective forces. These factors can have positive or negative impacts on sustainability under different contexts and conditions.

Therefore, the current economic system itself may not be inherently unsustainable, but certain specific economic mechanisms, decision-making processes, and the complex links between economic and natural systems may be the root causes of the problem. The paper suggests that mechanisms can be implemented to transform capitalist forces to support environmental protection, achieving short-term and mid-term sustainability; while long-term sustainability requires a deeper paradigm shift—fully integrating externalities and natural capital into the economic system.