Abstract:Importance: Concerns have been raised about the abuse liability of modern e-cigarettes that use acidic additives to form nicotine salts, making the inhalation of nicotine smoother than freebase nicotine. Objective: To examine the effects of nicotine form and concentration and e-liquid flavor on subjective effects ratings, vaping behavior, and nicotine uptake among young adults who use e-cigarettes. Design, setting, and participants: In this single-blind, within-participant, crossover randomized clinical trial, a convenience sample of young adults aged 21 to 25 years who currently used e-cigarettes was recruited from December 2021 to August 2023, for in-person research laboratory visits in Columbus, Ohio. Interventions: Participants completed up to 9 vaping sessions, starting with their usual e-cigarette brand in the first session followed by 1 of 8 laboratory-prepared e-liquids in a randomly assigned order in each subsequent session. Prepared e-liquids varied by nicotine form (salt-based vs freebase), nicotine concentration (5% vs 1% weight per weight), and flavor (menthol vs tobacco). Each session included a 5-minute, 10-puff standardized vaping period followed by 30 minutes of ad libitum vaping. Main outcomes and measures: At 4 time points (0, 5, 10, and 35 minutes) during each vaping session, plasma samples were collected for assessing nicotine uptake, and self-reports of urges, craving, and withdrawal were collected via questionnaires. Positive subjective effects were self-reported after 35 minutes of vaping using a visual analog scale; urges and cravings were reported using the Questionnaire of Smoking Urges (QSU). Puff topography data were collected throughout each vaping session. Results: Seventy-two participants (mean [SD] age, 22.4 [1.4] years; 42 [58.3%] female) who sampled at least 1 laboratory-prepared e-liquid composed the analytic sample. Salt-based (vs freebase) nicotine e-liquids increased nicotine intake, with 5% salt-based e-liquids delivering the highest mean plasma levels of nicotine (11.2 ng/mL [95% CI, 9.3-13.2 ng/mL] at 5 minutes; 17.2 ng/mL [95% CI, 14.3-20.1 ng/mL] at 35 minutes) irrespective of flavors. Higher positive subjective effect ratings (eg, for liking) were received by salt-based (42.8; 95% CI, 39.4-46.1) vs freebase (32.0; 95% CI, 28.6-35.3) nicotine, 1% (43.4; 95% CI, 40.2-46.6) vs 5% (31.2; 95% CI, 27.7-34.6) nicotine, and menthol-flavored (43.2; 95% CI, 39.7-46.7) vs tobacco-flavored (31.5; 95% CI, 28.4-34.7) e-liquids. Salt-based and 1% but not menthol-flavored nicotine elicited more intense puffing (eg, 25% [95% CI, 12%-40%] more total puffs for nicotine salts vs freebase). All study e-liquids reduced urges and cravings, with 5% vs 1% nicotine being more effective (mean [SE] QSU-Desire score at 35 minutes, 15.4 [0.5] vs 16.7 [0.5]). Conclusions and relevance: In this crossover randomized clinical trial among young adult e-cigarette users, salt-based (vs freebase) nicotine e-liquids increased nicotine intake and yielded more positive subjective effects ratings and intense puffing behaviors, suggesting higher abuse potential. Restricting the level of acidic additives and menthol flavoring may reduce the addictiveness of e-cigarettes. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05458895.

Does vaping affect the taste and smell perception? An exploratory study with New Zealand young adults

Exploring the opinions and potential impact of unflavoured e-liquid on smoking cessation among people who smoke and smoking relapse among people who previously smoked and now use e-cigarettes: findings from a UK-based mixed methods study

Chemical Analysis of Exhaled Vape Emissions: Unraveling the Complexities of Humectant Fragmentation in a Human Trial Study

Exposure to digital vape marketing among young people in Aotearoa New Zealand

Reprint of: Sex differences in appeal, reward, and sensory experience of E-cigarette flavors among adults who smoke cigarettes

Harm perceptions across vaping product features: An on‐line cross‐sectional survey of adults who smoke and/or vape in the United Kingdom

An observational human laboratory assessment of nicotine delivery, vaping topography and subjective effects of usual brand electronic cigarette use among young adults

Does sensation-seeking behavior influence the patterns of flavored e-cigarette use? A cross-sectional study among Indonesian adolescents and young adults

Do Flavor Descriptions Influence Subjective Ratings of Flavored and Unflavored E-liquids Among Nonsmoking and Non-vaping UK Adolescents?

The Use and Knowledge Around Vaping and Their Correlates Among University Students—A Cross-sectional Australian Study

Context matters: Neural processing of food-flavored e-cigarettes and the influence of smoking

Effect of packaging with versus without candy-oriented marketing themes on the appeal and sensory attributes of flavoured e-cigarettes

An experimental evaluation of the effects of banning the sale of flavored tobacco products on adolescents' and young adults' future nicotine vaping intentions

'Vaping is a break from all of that': Exploring attitudes, harm perceptions, cessation barriers and social dynamics among people who vape

Menthol Flavor in E-Cigarette Vapor Modulates Social Behavior Correlated With Central and Peripheral Changes of Immunometabolic Signalings

Non-tobacco nicotine E-cigarette use and flavored E-cigarette use among young adults in the United States

E-Cigarette Nicotine Delivery Among Young Adults by Nicotine Form, Concentration, and Flavor: A Crossover Randomized Clinical Trial

Electronic cigarette users' reactions and responses to a hypothetical ban of flavoured electronic cigarette liquids

Responses to potential nicotine vaping product flavor restrictions among regular vapers using non-tobacco flavors: Findings from the 2020 ITC Smoking and Vaping Survey in Canada, England and the United States

Perceptions and Use of Cannabis Vaping Products Amongst Youth: A Cross-Sectional Analysis of 1100 Cannabis Consumers

An Online Survey of New Zealand Vapers