Fixing the conformal window in QCD

Georges Grunberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.65.021701

2000-11-16

Abstract:A physical characterization of Landau singularities is emphasized, which should trace the lower boundary N_f^* of the conformal window in QCD and supersymmetric QCD. A natural way to disentangle ``perturbative'' from ``non-perturbative'' contributions to amplitudes below N_f^* is suggested. Assuming an infrared fixed point persists in the perturbative part of the QCD coupling even below N_f^* leads to the condition \gamma(N_f^*)=1, where \gamma is the critical exponent. Using the Banks-Zaks expansion, one gets 4<N_f^*<6. This result is incompatible with the existence of an analogue of Seiberg duality in QCD. The presence of a negative ultraviolet fixed point is required both in QCD and in supersymmetric QCD to preserve causality within the conformal window. Evidence for the existence of such a fixed point in QCD is provided.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the lower boundary \( N_f^* \) of the so - called "conformal window" in quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Specifically, the author explores how to distinguish between "perturbative" and "non - perturbative" contributions in QCD by studying the existence of Landau singularities and infrared fixed points, and proposes a method to determine the lower boundary of the conformal window.

### Specific problems and methods

1. **The relationship between Landau singularities and the conformal window**:
- The author assumes that Landau singularities can be traced to the lower boundary \( N_f^* \) of the conformal window. That is, when the number of flavors \( N_f \) is less than \( N_f^* \), causality in perturbation theory is violated and Landau singularities appear.

2. **The existence of infrared fixed points**:
- The author assumes that in some range where \( N_f < N_f^* \), the QCD coupling still has a non - trivial infrared fixed point \( \alpha_{IR} \). Based on this assumption, a condition is proposed: \( \gamma(N_f = N_f^*) = 1 \), where \( \gamma \) is the critical exponent, defined as the derivative of the β - function at the fixed point \( \gamma=\left.\frac{d\beta(\alpha)}{d\alpha}\right|_{\alpha = \alpha_{IR}} \).

3. **The application of Banks - Zaks expansion**:
- Use Banks - Zaks expansion to calculate the critical exponent \( \gamma \) and determine the value of \( N_f^* \). According to the existing expansion terms, the author concludes that \( 4\leq N_f^*\leq6 \).

4. **The requirement of UV fixed points**:
- In order to maintain causality, a negative UV fixed point \( \alpha_{UV} \) needs to exist. There is evidence to support this in both QCD and supersymmetric QCD (SQCD).

### Main conclusions

- **The lower boundary of the conformal window**: Through the above methods, the author determines that the lower boundary \( N_f^* \) of the conformal window is between 4 and 6.
- **The requirement of causality**: A negative UV fixed point is a necessary condition for maintaining causality.
- **The inconsistency of Seiberg duality**: The obtained results are inconsistent with the possibility of the existence of Seiberg - like duality in QCD.

### Formula summary

- **The definition of the critical exponent**:
\[
\gamma=\left.\frac{d\beta(\alpha)}{d\alpha}\right|_{\alpha = \alpha_{IR}}
\]

- **The critical exponent of Banks - Zaks expansion**:
\[
\gamma = \frac{107}{16}a^2\left(1 + 4.75a-8.89a^2+\cdots\right)
\]
where \( a=\frac{8}{321}(16.5 - N_f) \).

- **The existence condition of UV fixed points**:
\[
\beta(\alpha)=-\beta_0\alpha^2-\beta_1\alpha^3-\beta_2\alpha^4+\cdots
\]

Through these analyses, the author provides a physically intuitive and mathematically rigorous method to determine the lower boundary of the conformal window in QCD and discusses its impact on the theoretical structure of QCD.