The nuclear force in the third millennium

R. Machleidt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0375-9474%2801%2900814-4

2000-09-23

Abstract:I will review recent progress in our understanding of the nuclear force. In the course of the 1990's, so-called high-precision, charge-dependent nucleon-nucleon potentials have been constructed which are, essentially, phenomenological models. These potentials are now commonly used as input for exact few-body calculations and microscopic nuclear many-body theory. I will critically analyses those models and point out their strenghts and weaknesses. Particular emphasis will be on charge dependence. Other recent research was conducted on a more basic level: understanding the nuclear force in terms of the fundamental theory of strong interactions, QCD. Predictions from this sector are typically qualitative in nature. Thus, the main problem of the current status in the field is that quantitative models for the nuclear force have a poor theoretical background, while theory based models yield poor results. The chief challenge for the new millenium is to overcome this discrepancy. Chiral effective field theory may be a suitable tool to solve the problem.

Nuclear Theory,Nuclear Experiment

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inconsistency between the theory and practice of nuclear forces. Specifically, currently, the models for quantitatively describing nuclear forces lack a solid theoretical foundation, while the theory - based models are unable to give accurate results. This gap between theory and practice became more obvious in the 1990s.

### Specific manifestations of the problem

1. **Weak theoretical background of quantitative models**: Although the existing high - precision, charge - dependent nucleon - nucleon (NN) potential models can fit experimental data very well ($\chi^{2}$/datum $\approx$ 1), most of these models are empirically constructed and lack solid theoretical support.

2. **Poor results of theoretical models**: Due to the non - perturbative nature of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) in the low - energy region, attempts to derive nuclear forces from QCD cannot directly solve the problem. Therefore, so - called "QCD - related" or "QCD - inspired" models usually can only give qualitative predictions, and if quantitative results are to be obtained, the traditional meson - exchange mechanism often needs to be introduced.

### Main objectives of the paper

The main objective of the paper is to overcome the above - mentioned inconsistency between theory and practice and find a method that can both provide quantitative results and have a solid theoretical foundation. To this end, the author proposes:

- **The concept of effective field theory (EFT)**: In particular, chiral perturbation theory ($\chi$PT) may be a suitable tool. As an effective theory in the low - energy region, $\chi$PT can perform accurate calculations while maintaining theoretical systematization.

- **Application of chiral perturbation theory**: Through the ideas of chiral symmetry and spontaneous breaking, $\chi$PT can describe strong interactions in the low - energy region and gradually improve the description of nuclear forces, thus bridging the gap between theory and practice.

### Summary

The problem that the paper attempts to solve is the current situation where the quantitative models of nuclear forces lack theoretical support and the theoretical models cannot give accurate results. By introducing chiral perturbation theory, the author hopes to find a method that can both provide quantitative results and have a solid theoretical foundation, thereby promoting the development of nuclear force research.