Chung-Pei Ma,J. N. Fry
Abstract:An analytical understanding of the strongly nonlinear regime of gravitational collapse has been difficult to achieve. The only insight has been the stable clustering hypothesis, which assumes that the number of neighbors for objects averaged over small length scales is constant in time. Our recently proposed analytic halo model for N-point correlation functions now provides a tool for calculating gravitational clustering properties in the strongly nonlinear regime. This model also provides a new physical framework for an independent evaluation of the validity of the stable clustering hypothesis. We derive the asymptotic nonlinear behavior of the N-point correlation functions and pairwise peculiar velocities in terms of dark matter halo properties. We show that these statistics exhibit stable clustering only when the halo mass function and halo density profile obey specific relations. The long-cherished stable clustering hypothesis therefore is not necessarily realized in practice.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the strongly nonlinear phase of gravitational collapse and evaluate the validity of the stable clustering hypothesis. Specifically, the author explores whether the properties of dark matter halos (such as the mass function and density distribution) in the strongly nonlinear phase meet the conditions of the stable clustering hypothesis. By constructing an analytical halo model, the author hopes to reveal these conditions and provide an independent verification for the stable clustering hypothesis.
### Background of the Stable Clustering Hypothesis
The Stable Clustering Hypothesis assumes that on small scales, the number of neighbors of an object remains constant over time. This hypothesis allows us to extrapolate in the nonlinear region that numerical simulations cannot reach. According to this hypothesis, the predicted results include:
1. The two - point correlation function \(\xi(r)\) and the power spectrum \(P(k)\) are in the form of power laws:
\[
\xi(r)\propto r^{-\gamma}, \quad \Delta(k)\equiv4\pi k^3 P(k)\propto k^\gamma
\]
where \(\gamma = \frac{9 + 3n}{5 + n}\), and \(n\) is the primordial spectral index.
2. The high - order N - point correlation function \(\xi_N(r)\) satisfies:
\[
\xi_N(r)\propto r^{-\gamma_N}, \quad \gamma_N=(N - 1)\gamma
\]
3. The pairwise peculiar velocity \(v\) exactly cancels the Hubble expansion on small scales:
\[
\frac{v}{Hr}=- 1
\]
### Main Contributions of the Paper
By constructing an analytical halo model, the author studies the behavior of the N - point correlation function and the pairwise peculiar velocity in the strongly nonlinear phase. They find that the stable clustering hypothesis holds only under specific conditions, namely:
- The mass function and concentration parameter of the halo must satisfy certain relationships.
- For the two - point correlation function, \(\alpha\) and \(\beta\) need to satisfy:
\[
\frac{18\beta-\alpha(n + 3)}{2(3\beta + 1)}=\frac{9 + 3n}{5 + n}
\]
- For the third - order and higher - order correlation functions, \(\alpha = 0\) or \(n=-3\) is required.
### Conclusion
The paper concludes that the stable clustering hypothesis does not always hold in practice, especially within the parameter ranges obtained from current numerical simulations. This indicates that when dealing with strongly nonlinear gravitational collapse, existing fitting formulas need to be modified, especially in the high - \(k\) value region (for example, \(k/k_{nl}\gtrsim50\) for the \(n = - 2\) model, or \(k\gtrsim20h\text{Mpc}^{-1}\) for the cold dark matter model with a cosmological constant).
In summary, this paper provides new insights through the analytical halo model, reveals the complex behavior of gravitational clustering in the strongly nonlinear phase, and challenges the long - accepted stable clustering hypothesis.