Wave propagation in linear electrodynamics

Yuri N. Obukhov,Tetsuo Fukui,Guillermo Rubilar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.62.044050

2000-05-06

Abstract:The Fresnel equation governing the propagation of electromagnetic waves for the most general linear constitutive law is derived. The wave normals are found to lie, in general, on a fourth order surface. When the constitutive coefficients satisfy the so-called reciprocity or closure relation, one can define a duality operator on the space of the two-forms. We prove that the closure relation is a sufficient condition for the reduction of the fourth order surface to the familiar second order light cone structure. We finally study whether this condition is also necessary.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the propagation characteristics of electromagnetic waves in the most general linear electromagnetic media, especially to derive the Fresnel equations that govern such propagation. Specifically:

1. **Derivation of the Fresnel equations**: The author derived the Fresnel equations that describe the propagation of electromagnetic waves in media with the most general linear constitutive relations. This equation determines the direction of the wave - front normal, and in general these normals lie on a fourth - order surface.

2. **Study of the influence of the closure condition**: When the constitutive coefficients satisfy the so - called "reciprocity" or "closure relations", a dual operator on the two - form space can be defined. The paper proved that the closure relation is a sufficient condition for simplifying the fourth - order surface to the familiar quadratic light - cone structure. In addition, the author also explored whether this condition is also necessary.

3. **Analysis of the relationship between fourth - order and quadratic wave geometries**: The paper discussed the relationship between the fourth - order wave geometric structure (i.e., the fourth - order surface) and the quadratic wave geometric structure (i.e., the light - cone structure), and paid special attention to the role of the closure condition in this transformation.

### Main formulas

- **Linear constitutive relation**:
\[
H_{ij}=\frac{1}{4}\epsilon_{ijkl}\chi^{klmn}F_{mn}
\]
where \(\chi^{klmn}\) is the constitutive tensor density.

- **Fresnel equation**:
\[
W:=\det\left|q_0^2A_{ab}+q_0q_d\left[C_a^c\epsilon_{cdb}+C_b^c\epsilon_{cda}\right]+q_eq_f\epsilon_{aec}\epsilon_{bfd}B^{cd}\right| = 0
\]

- **Closure relation**:
\[
\frac{1}{4}\epsilon_{ijmn}\epsilon_{pqrk}\chi^{mnpq}\chi^{rskl}=-\delta^{kl}_{ij}
\]

### Conclusion

The main conclusion of the paper is that the closure relation is a sufficient condition for simplifying the fourth - order wave geometric structure to the quadratic light - cone structure, and in some specific cases, this condition is also necessary. These results are of great significance for understanding the propagation behavior of electromagnetic waves in complex media, especially having wide applications in fields such as crystal optics.