V. Hnizdo
Abstract:The self-force of classical electrodynamics on a charged "rigid" body of radius R is evaluated analytically for the body undergoing a slow (i.e., with a speed v<<c), slight (i.e., small compared to R), and temporary displacement from an initial position of rest. The results are relevant to the Bohr-Rosenfeld analysis of the measurability of the electromagnetic field, which has been the subject of a recent controversy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the self - force problem of charged rigid bodies in classical electromagnetism when they experience slow and small temporary displacements. Specifically, the author aims to:
1. **Evaluate the self - force of a charged sphere under specific motion conditions**: The paper analyzes the self - force on a charged "rigid body" with radius \(R\) when it undergoes a slow, small, and temporary displacement from its rest position. The velocity \(v\) of this displacement is \(v\ll c\), that is, much less than the speed of light, and the amount of displacement is very small relative to the size of the object.
2. **Verify the validity of the Bohr - Rosenfeld analysis**: Bohr and Rosenfeld proposed an eight - dimensional integral expression in their research on the measurability of electromagnetic fields to describe the time - average of the self - force plus the electrostatic force. This result has been controversial in recent years, especially regarding the rationality of using step - like trajectories. The author hopes to verify the validity of the Bohr - Rosenfeld result through the analysis of non - step - like trajectories.
3. **Provide an analytical solution**: The author obtains the analytical expressions for the time - dependence and time - average of the self - force of a charged sphere under specific motion conditions by the method of direct integration rather than the Fourier transform method. These expressions are relatively simple and are consistent with the results obtained previously by the Fourier transform method.
4. **Discuss the controversial points**: The paper also discusses the质疑 of Compagno and Persico (CP) on the Bohr - Rosenfeld method, and proves that the BR result is correct under appropriate conditions through detailed calculations, thus responding to CP's criticism.
### Formula summary
- **Time - averaged self - force**:
\[
\bar{F}_x=\frac{\rho^2}{cV^2}\int_{0}^{T}dt_1D_x(t_1)f(t_1)
\]
where,
\[
f(t_1)=-\frac{1}{R^3}[\Theta(T - t_1)-\Theta(-t_1)]-\frac{2}{3}[I(T - t_1)-I(-t_1)]
\]
- **Time - dependence of the self - force**:
\[
F_x(t_2)=-\frac{3\rho^2}{cV^2R^3}D_x(t_2)+\frac{3\rho^2V^2}{R^3}\Theta(t_2)\sum_{n = 0}^{\infty}\frac{R^nD^{(n)}_x(0+)}{(n + 3)!}\left[a_n(\kappa)\Theta(\kappa - 2)\Theta(2-\xi)+b_n(\kappa)\kappa^{n+1}\Theta(-\xi)+c_n(\kappa)\Theta(\xi)\Theta(2-\xi)\right]
\]
- **Geometric factor**:
\[
\bar{A}_{xx}(I, I)=-\frac{1}{R^4}\kappa^{-1}\frac{8}{R^4}\kappa(4+\kappa)(2-\kappa)^2\Theta(2-\kappa)
\]
Through these formulas, the author analyzes in detail the self - force behavior of charged spheres under different conditions and verifies the correctness of the Bohr - Rosenfeld result.