Reply to a review of photon-exchange interactions by Opatrny and Kurizki

J. D. Franson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/1521-3978%28200009%2948%3A9/11%3C1133%3A%3AAID-PROP1133%3E3.0.CO%3B2-B
2000-03-18
Abstract:In a recent review article, Opatrny and Kurizki [submitted to Fortschr. Phys., e-print <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="quant-ph/0003010" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0003010">quant-ph/0003010</a>] discussed a number of issues related to the feasibility of quantum computation based on photon-exchange interactions. This Reply summarizes my view of each of the issues and the overall prospects for quantum computing based on photon-exchange interactions.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the proper time of neutrinos and their path characteristics, especially whether different types of neutrinos (electron neutrinos, muon neutrinos, and tau neutrinos) have different internal clocks. Specifically, the paper explores the following issues: 1. **The relationship between the quantum phase of neutrinos and their paths**: The paper discusses how the paths of neutrinos in space - time affect their quantum phases and proposes that neutrinos may have different internal clocks, similar to the internal clocks of electrons, muons, and taus. 2. **Space - like paths of muon neutrinos**: The paper assumes that muon neutrinos may propagate along space - like paths, which means that their momentum directions are not in line with their displacement directions. This may cause some atmospheric muon neutrinos to move backward into outer space and thus cannot be detected. This phenomenon can explain the observed decrease in the atmospheric muon neutrino flux in the Super - Kamiokande experiment. 3. **Time - like or light - like paths of electron neutrinos**: The paper points out that since no decrease in the electron neutrino flux has been observed and electron neutrinos arrived at the Earth almost simultaneously with light during the SN1987A supernova explosion, it is inferred that electron neutrinos propagate along time - like or light - like paths. 4. **Experimental design for validating the model**: The paper proposes that the backward movement of muon neutrinos can be verified through accelerator experiments, that is, placing detectors upstream of pion or muon beams to detect muon neutrinos carrying reverse momentum. ### Main conclusions - **Absence of muon neutrinos**: The paper calculates that if muon neutrinos propagate along space - like paths, approximately 9% of muon neutrinos will move backward into outer space, resulting in a decrease of about 9% in the observed atmospheric muon neutrino flux in the Super - Kamiokande experiment, which can explain some of the observed results. - **Paths of electron neutrinos**: Since no decrease in the electron neutrino flux has been observed and the observations of SN1987A support that electron neutrinos propagate along light - like paths, it is inferred that electron neutrinos propagate along time - like or light - like paths. Through these discussions, the paper attempts to explain the anomalies in the atmospheric neutrino flux observations and proposes new experimental schemes to verify these hypotheses.