Coexistent State of Charge Density Wave and Spin Density Wave in One-Dimensional Quarter Filled Band Systems under Magnetic Fields

Keita Kishigi,Yasumasa Hasegawa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1143/JPSJ.69.2145

2000-02-15

Abstract:We theoretically study how the coexistent state of the charge density wave and the spin density wave in the one-dimensional quarter filled band is enhanced by magnetic fields. We found that when the correlation between electrons is strong the spin density wave state is suppressed under high magnetic fields, whereas the charge density wave state still remains. This will be observed in experiments such as the X-ray measurement.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the behavior of the coexistence state of charge - density - wave (CDW) and spin - density - wave (SDW) in a one - dimensional quarter - filled band system under a magnetic field. Specifically, the author studies how this coexistence state is affected by the magnetic field when the correlation between electrons is strong.

### Research Background

In a one - dimensional quarter - filled band system, due to the combined effect of the on - site Coulomb interaction \( U \) and the nearest - neighbor Coulomb interaction \( V \), the system can form a coexistence state of charge - density - wave (CDW) and spin - density - wave (SDW). Typical examples of such systems include quasi - one - dimensional organic conductors such as (TMTSF)₂X and (TMTTF)₂X.

### Research Questions

1. **Coexistence State in Strong - Correlation Systems**: When the correlation between electrons is strong (that is, \( U/t \) and \( V/t \) are large), how will the coexistence state of CDW and SDW change under magnetic fields in different directions?
2. **Coexistence State in Weak - Correlation Systems**: When the correlation between electrons is weak (that is, \( U/t \) and \( V/t \) are small), how will the coexistence state of CDW and SDW change under magnetic fields in different directions?
3. **Experimental Verification**: Can these theoretical predictions be verified by experimental means (such as X - ray measurements)?

### Main Findings

- **Strong - Correlation Systems**:
- Under a high magnetic field, the spin - density - wave (SDW) state is suppressed, while the charge - density - wave (CDW) state still exists.
- When the magnetic field is applied along the a - axis or b - axis, CDW and SDW will not be affected because the nesting vector is not affected by the Zeeman effect.

- **Weak - Correlation Systems**:
- In the Pauli paramagnetic limit field, both CDW and SDW will disappear.
- When the magnetic field is applied along the c - axis, the diamagnetic state remains stable along the c - axis, but at a higher critical field \( H_0^z \), the paramagnetic state becomes more stable.

### Experimental Comparison

The paper also discusses the comparison between experimental results and theoretical models, especially in strong - correlation systems such as (TMTTF)₂X and (DCNQI)₂Ag. Even under a high magnetic field, charge ordering (4kF - CDW) may still exist and can be observed by X - ray measurements.

### Conclusion

Through theoretical research, the author finds that in strong - correlation systems, although a high magnetic field will suppress spin ordering, charge ordering can still be maintained. In weak - correlation systems, CDW and SDW will disappear in the Pauli paramagnetic limit field. These characteristics should be observable through experiments in strong - correlation systems (such as (TMTTF)₂X and (DCNQI)₂Ag) and non - strong - correlation systems (such as (TMTSF)₂X).

### Formula Summary

The main formulas involved in the paper include:

- Pauli Paramagnetic Limit Field:
\[
h_p = 2\sqrt{-\pi E_g \sqrt{2N_S}}
\]
where \( h_p=\mu_B g H_p / 2t \), \( E_g \) is the energy gain, and \( N_S \) is the total number of lattice points.

- Variation of Spin Moment with Magnetic Field:
\[
S_z(H, j)/S_z(0, j)=\sqrt{1-\left(\frac{H}{H_0^x}\right)^2}
\]

These formulas are used to describe the influence of the magnetic field on spin and charge ordering.